Obstetricians and the American circumcision scandal

From IntactiWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Construction Site

This article is work in progress and not yet part of the free encyclopedia IntactiWiki.

 

The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists is a medical trade association that provides a statement on its website to encourage parents to consent to harmful, injurious circumcision of the newborn. Obstetricians have long been a major factor in the promotion and performance of circumcision of the newborn.

ACOG information for parents

The infamous 2012 statement for parents appears to have been removed in 2017 at the time that the 2012 American Academy of Pediatrics Circumcision Policy Statement expired.

It was replaced in 2017 by another statement that shows signs of concerns about the possible legal liability of ACOG. The statement attempts to move the responsibility and liability for any circumcision from the surgeon to the parent. Some of the claims that advocate circumcision have been omitted. There is a claim that circumcision may reduce the risk of urinary tract infection (UTI), but it fails to tell parents that the treatment for UTI is with anti-microbial drugs, not surgery.[1]

[2]

Statement by George C. Denniston, M.D., M.P.H.

George C. Denniston, M. D., M.P.H. (2025) commented:

Some obstetricians also routinely cut half of the normal skin from the normal penises of the newborn males whom they have just delivered. They do it without medical indication, and they continue to do it despite the overwhelming evidence of harm. There is no way of getting around the fact that these doctors are torturing and mutilating their patients at the rate of 3300 newborn males every day in the United States. It is totally amazing that Americans permit doctors to continue to commit these atrocities on a daily basis. They should pass a law, which is probably the only way to stop this compulsion.[3]

  • REFweb {{#if:Alissa|{{#if:Kristel Alissa|{{#if:|Alissa |Alissa{{#if:Kristel|, Kristel|}}}}|{{#if:|Alissa |Alissa{{#if:Kristel|, Kristel|}}|}}|}}|}}{{#if:2025-07-03|{{#if:Alissa| ({{#switch:{{#invoke:String|len|s=2025-07-03}}
|0 |1 |2 =
|3 |4 |5 = {{#time:Y|2025-07-03 }}
|6 |7 |8 = {{#time:F Y|2025-07-03 }}
|9 |10 = {{#time:j F Y|2025-07-03 }}
|#default = error

}}). |({{#switch:{{#invoke:String|len|s=2025-07-03}} 

|0 |1 |2 =
|3 |4 |5 = {{#time:Y|2025-07-03 }}
|6 |7 |8 = {{#time:F Y|2025-07-03 }}
|9 |10 = {{#time:j F Y|2025-07-03 }}
|#default = error

}}). }}|{{#if:Alissa|. |}}}}{{#if:https://intactamerica.org/foreskin-functions-you-were-never-told/%7C{{#if:The Penis You Were Supposed to Have: 10 Functions of the Foreskin You Were Never Taught|The Penis You Were Supposed to Have: 10 Functions of the Foreskin You Were Never Taught{{#if:| File:Icons-mini-file pdf.svg|}}|[<title> parameter missing!]}}|[<url> parameter missing!]{{#if:The Penis You Were Supposed to Have: 10 Functions of the Foreskin You Were Never Taught|The Penis You Were Supposed to Have: 10 Functions of the Foreskin You Were Never Taught|[<title> parameter missing!]}}{{#if:| (PDF)|}}}}{{#ifeq:|yes| (archive URL)|}}{{#if:| [{{{trans-title}}}]{{#if:| ({{{language}}})|}}|}}{{#if:|, {{{website}}}|}}{{#if: |, {{{work}}} [deprecated REFweb parameter used: use <website> instead]|}}{{#if:Intact America|, Intact America|}}{{#if:2025-07-06|. Retrieved {{#switch:{{#invoke:String|len|s=2025-07-06}} 

|0 |1 |2 =
|3 |4 |5 = {{#time:Y|2025-07-06 }}
|6 |7 |8 = {{#time:F Y|2025-07-06 }}
|9 |10 = {{#time:j F Y|2025-07-06 }}
|#default = error

}}|}}.{{#if:|
Quote: {{{quote}}}|}}

References

  1. ↑ REFjournal {{#if:McCracken, Jr.|{{#if:|{{#if:GH|[[|McCracken, Jr. GH]]|[[|McCracken, Jr.{{#if:|, |}}]]}}|{{#if:GH|McCracken, Jr. GH|McCracken, Jr.{{#if:|, |}}|}}|}}|}}{{#if:|{{#if:|{{#if:|, [[{{{author2-link}}}|{{{last2}}} {{{init2}}}]]|, [[{{{author2-link}}}|{{{last2}}}{{#if:|, {{{first2}}}|}}]]}}|{{#if:|, {{{last2}}} {{{init2}}}|, {{{last2}}}{{#if:|, {{{first2}}}|}}|}}|}}|}}{{#if:|{{#if:|{{#if:|, [[{{{author3-link}}}|{{{last3}}} {{{init3}}}]]|, [[{{{author3-link}}}|{{{last3}}}{{#if:|, {{{first3}}}|}}]]}}|{{#if:|, {{{last3}}} {{{init3}}}|, {{{last3}}}{{#if:|, {{{first3}}}|}}|}}|}}|}}{{#if:|{{#if:|{{#if:|, [[{{{author4-link}}}|{{{last4}}} {{{init4}}}]]|, [[{{{author4-link}}}|{{{last4}}}{{#if:|, {{{first4}}}|}}]]}}|{{#if:|, {{{last4}}} {{{init4}}}|, {{{last4}}}{{#if:|, {{{first4}}}|}}|}}|}}|}}{{#if:|{{#if:|{{#if:|, [[{{{author5-link}}}|{{{last5}}} {{{init5}}}]]|, [[{{{author5-link}}}|{{{last5}}}{{#if:|, {{{first5}}}|}}]]}}|{{#if:|, {{{last5}}} {{{init5}}}|, {{{last5}}}{{#if:|, {{{first5}}}|}}|}}|}}|}}{{#if:|{{#if:|{{#if:|, [[{{{author6-link}}}|{{{last6}}} {{{init6}}}]]|, [[{{{author6-link}}}|{{{last6}}}{{#if:|, {{{first6}}}|}}]]}}|{{#if:|, {{{last6}}} {{{init6}}}|, {{{last6}}}{{#if:|, {{{first6}}}|}}|}}|}}|}}{{#if:|{{#if:|{{#if:|, [[{{{author7-link}}}|{{{last7}}} {{{init7}}}]]|, [[{{{author7-link}}}|{{{last7}}}{{#if:|, {{{first7}}}|}}]]}}|{{#if:|, {{{last7}}} {{{init7}}}|, {{{last7}}}{{#if:|, {{{first7}}}|}}|}}|}}|}}{{#if:|{{#if:|{{#if:|, [[{{{author8-link}}}|{{{last8}}} {{{init8}}}]]|, [[{{{author8-link}}}|{{{last8}}}{{#if:|, {{{first8}}}|}}]]}}|{{#if:|, {{{last8}}} {{{init8}}}|, {{{last8}}}{{#if:|, {{{first8}}}|}}|}}|}}|}}{{#if:|{{#if:|{{#if:|, [[{{{author9-link}}}|{{{last9}}} {{{init9}}}]]|, [[{{{author9-link}}}|{{{last9}}}{{#if:|, {{{first9}}}|}}]]}}|{{#if:|, {{{last9}}} {{{init9}}}|, {{{last9}}}{{#if:|, {{{first9}}}|}}|}}|}}|}}{{#if:|; with {{{coauthors}}} [deprecated REFjournal parameter used: <coauthors> - please use <last2>, etc.]|}}{{#ifeq:no|yes|, et al.|{{#if:McCracken, Jr.|.|}}}}{{#if:| ({{{publisher}}})|}} {{#if:https://www.cirp.org/library/disease/UTI/mccracken/%7COptions in antimicrobial management of urinary tract infections in infants and children{{#if:| PDF|}}{{#ifeq:|yes| (archive URL)|}}|Options in antimicrobial management of urinary tract infections in infants and children}}{{#if:| [{{{trans-title}}}]{{#if:| ({{{language}}})|}}|}}{{#if:Pediatr Infect Dis J|. Pediatr Infect Dis J{{#if:| ()}}.|}}{{#if:1989-08| {{#switch:{{#invoke:String|len|s=1989-08}} |0 |1 |2 = |3 |4 |5 = {{#time:Y|1989-08 }} |6 |7 |8 = {{#time:F Y|1989-08 }} |9 |10 = {{#time:j F Y|1989-08 }} |#default = error }}{{#if:| ({{{season}}})|}}; | }}{{#if:8| 8|}}{{#if:8|(8)|}}{{#if: 552--5|{{#if:|: [{{{article}}}]|}}{{#if:|: {{{page}}}|}}{{#if:552--5|: 552--5|}}.|}}{{#if:2771540| PMID.|}}{{#if:| PMC.|}}{{#if:10.1097/00006454-198908000-00041| DOI.|}}{{#if:| DOI.|}}{{#if:2025-07-07| Retrieved {{#switch:{{#invoke:String|len|s=2025-07-07}} |0 |1 |2 = |3 |4 |5 = {{#time:Y|2025-07-07 }} |6 |7 |8 = {{#time:F Y|2025-07-07 }} |9 |10 = {{#time:j F Y|2025-07-07 }} |#default = error }}.|}}{{#if:Because long term outcome of UTI in uncircumcised males is unknown, it is inappropriate at this time to recommend circumcision as a routine medically indicated procedure.|
    Quote: Because long term outcome of UTI in uncircumcised males is unknown, it is inappropriate at this time to recommend circumcision as a routine medically indicated procedure.|}}
  2. ↑ REFweb {{#if:Anonymous|{{#if:|{{#if:|[[|Anonymous ]]|[[|Anonymous{{#if:|, |}}]]}}|{{#if:|Anonymous |Anonymous{{#if:|, |}}|}}|}}|}}{{#if:2017|{{#if:Anonymous| ({{#switch:{{#invoke:String|len|s=2017}} |0 |1 |2 = |3 |4 |5 = {{#time:Y|2017 }} |6 |7 |8 = {{#time:F Y|2017 }} |9 |10 = {{#time:j F Y|2017 }} |#default = error }}). |({{#switch:{{#invoke:String|len|s=2017}} |0 |1 |2 = |3 |4 |5 = {{#time:Y|2017 }} |6 |7 |8 = {{#time:F Y|2017 }} |9 |10 = {{#time:j F Y|2017 }} |#default = error }}). }}|{{#if:Anonymous|. |}}}}{{#if:https://www.acog.org/womens-health/faqs/newborn-male-circumcision%7C{{#if:Newborn Male Circumcision|Newborn Male Circumcision{{#if:| File:Icons-mini-file pdf.svg|}}|[<title> parameter missing!]}}|[<url> parameter missing!]{{#if:Newborn Male Circumcision|Newborn Male Circumcision|[<title> parameter missing!]}}{{#if:| (PDF)|}}}}{{#ifeq:|yes| (archive URL)|}}{{#if:| [{{{trans-title}}}]{{#if:| ({{{language}}})|}}|}}{{#if:|, {{{website}}}|}}{{#if: |, {{{work}}} [deprecated REFweb parameter used: use <website> instead]|}}{{#if:ACOG|, ACOG|}}{{#if:2025-07-07|. Retrieved {{#switch:{{#invoke:String|len|s=2025-07-07}} |0 |1 |2 = |3 |4 |5 = {{#time:Y|2025-07-07 }} |6 |7 |8 = {{#time:F Y|2025-07-07 }} |9 |10 = {{#time:j F Y|2025-07-07 }} |#default = error }}|}}.{{#if:|
    Quote: {{{quote}}}|}}
  3. ↑ REFbook {{#if:Denniston|{{#if:George C. Denniston|Denniston{{#if:GC| GC|{{#if:|, |}}}}|Denniston{{#if:GC| GC|{{#if:|, |}}}}}}}}{{#if:|, {{#if:|[[|{{#if:| |{{#if:|, |}}}}]]|{{#if:| |{{#if:|, |}}}}}}}}{{#if:|, {{#if:|[[{{{author3-link}}}|{{{last3}}}{{#if:| {{{init3}}}|{{#if:|, {{{first3}}}|}}}}]]|{{{last3}}}{{#if:| {{{init3}}}|{{#if:|, {{{first3}}}|}}}}}}}}{{#if:|, {{#if:|[[{{{author4-link}}}|{{{last4}}}{{#if:| {{{init4}}}|{{#if:|, {{{first4}}}|}}}}]]|{{{last4}}}{{#if:| {{{init4}}}|{{#if:|, {{{first4}}}|}}}}}}}}{{#if:|, {{#if:|[[{{{author5-link}}}|{{{last5}}}{{#if:| {{{init5}}}|{{#if:|, {{{first5}}}|}}}}]]|{{{last5}}}{{#if:| {{{init5}}}|{{#if:|, {{{first5}}}|}}}}}}}}{{#if:|, {{#if:|[[{{{author6-link}}}|{{{last6}}}{{#if:| {{{init6}}}|{{#if:|, {{{first6}}}|}}}}]]|{{{last6}}}{{#if:| {{{init6}}}|{{#if:|, {{{first6}}}|}}}}}}}}{{#if:|, {{#if:|[[{{{author7-link}}}|{{{last7}}}{{#if:| {{{init7}}}|{{#if:|, {{{first7}}}|}}}}]]|{{{last7}}}{{#if:| {{{init7}}}|{{#if:|, {{{first7}}}|}}}}}}}}{{#if:|, {{#if:|[[{{{author8-link}}}|{{{last8}}}{{#if:| {{{init8}}}|{{#if:|, {{{first8}}}|}}}}]]|{{{last8}}}{{#if:| {{{init8}}}|{{#if:|, {{{first8}}}|}}}}}}}}{{#if:|, {{#if:|[[{{{author9-link}}}|{{{last9}}}{{#if:| {{{init9}}}|{{#if:|, {{{first9}}}|}}}}]]|{{{last9}}}{{#if:| {{{init9}}}|{{#if:|, {{{first9}}}|}}}}}}}}{{#if:2025| (2025{{#if:| [{{{year-initial}}}]}})|}}{{#if:Denniston|:|}}{{#if:| , in:|}}{{#if:| [ Never a Dull Moment: The Life of an Activist Physician]{{#ifeq:|yes| (archive URL)|}}.| Never a Dull Moment: The Life of an Activist Physician.}}{{#if:| [{{{trans-title}}}]}}{{#if:| ({{{language}}}).}}{{#if:| Work: .|}}{{#if:| (ed.).|}}{{#if:| {{{editors}}} (eds.).|}}{{#if:| Edition: .|}}{{#if:| Vol. .|}}{{#if:| pages.|}}{{#if:Van Nuys| Van Nuys|}}{{#if:Donald A. Collins Publishing|{{#if:Van Nuys|:|}} Donald A. Collins Publishing.|}}{{#if:| P. .|}}{{#if:39-40| Pp. 39-40.|}}{{#if:9798287592585| ISBN {{#if:9798287592585|9798287592585|}}.|}}{{#if:| ISBN {{#if:{{{isbn}}}|[[Special:BookSources/{{{isbn}}}|{{{isbn}}}]]|}}.|}}{{#if:| DOI.|}}{{#if:2025-07-06| Retrieved {{#switch:{{#invoke:String|len|s=2025-07-06}} |0 |1 |2 = |3 |4 |5 = {{#time:Y|2025-07-06 }} |6 |7 |8 = {{#time:F Y|2025-07-06 }} |9 |10 = {{#time:j F Y|2025-07-06 }} |#default = error }}.|}}{{#if:|
    Quote: |}}{{#if:|
    Note: |}}
Retrieved from "https://en.intactiwiki.org/w/index.php?title=Obstetricians_and_the_American_circumcision_scandal&oldid=42726"