Medical ethics - Revision history

WikiModEn2: /* Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision */ Change URL.

2023-05-28T17:34:36Z

Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision: Change URL.

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:34, 28 May 2023
Line 133:		Line 133:
	\|issue=7		\|issue=7
	\|pages=560-72		\|pages=560-72
	\|url=https://~~d1wqtxts1xzle7~~.~~cloudfront~~.net/~~64630392~~/~~bioe.12714~~-~~libre.pdf?1602188733=&response~~-~~content~~-disposition=inline%3B+filename%3DWhat_is_the_best_age_to_circumcise_A_med.pdf&Expires=1685274798&Signature=fHTGStEInBR4aJERFVi6YaSi84Xt4X2m7Q43zBQIHsDQ6VC1Tzy4mhvJDxumH0JTqBo45iPvE0fty6xejNJZZ9POvPnkHzLxYhjvPQUFANKgSDctUShGvt~HV~-~~FVSyXU8SbfQHZ9tS72ZbOyRuJc3YGBwAgvDrQ0oZ3aJxUSI28IoFD8raIxeAPtgbBFQ6cd0JNTy6GVRdIPTBzOlKiM4h4R9mwBhh0dfnpsZSGdlpxdIdpe89vDU4cwDLqujE4RPtej7YbTmY3KMrmgI6~~--~~dCqBpSLeIr9nJaKKJo~~-~~cLSdqLNct7vjn77K9A3~~--~~FZ2aTUHtCBVJPdx7P4fJ0cAyA__&Key~~-~~Pair~~-~~Id=APKAJLOHF5GGSLRBV4ZA~~		\|url=https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Brian-Earp-2/publication/337720859_What_Is_the_Best_Age_to_Circumcise_A_Medical_and_Ethical_Analysis/links/5f815f61a6fdccfd7b555395/What-Is-the-Best-Age-to-Circumcise-A-Medical-and-Ethical-Analysis.pdf
	\|archived=		\|archived=
	\|quote=		\|quote=

WikiModEn2: /* Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision */

2023-05-28T12:43:49Z

Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision

@@ Line 139: / Line 139: @@
   |pubmedCID=
   |DOI=10.1111/bioe.12714
   |accessdate=2023-05-23
 }}</ref> Consent by a surrogate for a non-therapeutic circumcision is an unethical practice.

WikiModEn2: /* Minimum age for non-therapeutic circumcision */ Update URL.

2023-05-28T11:06:20Z

Minimum age for non-therapeutic circumcision: Update URL.

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:06, 28 May 2023
Line 133:		Line 133:
	\|issue=7		\|issue=7
	\|pages=560-72		\|pages=560-72
	\|url=https://d1wqtxts1xzle7.cloudfront.net/64630392/bioe.12714-libre.pdf?1602188733=&response-content-disposition=inline%3B+filename%3DWhat_is_the_best_age_to_circumcise_A_med.pdf&Expires=~~1684876293~~&Signature=~~d1KDXgVkLXAEhblZPrx1j1QmGLHyBG5Hu26oi5RVrbGMxVHo0nLvrJ5fJMIusVa72yX-C6LFaw7dxGUa~~~~~ot6ooc9jIXaR6gnA2U98~~~~~8PFtWeMwZO8Jzszcl02iF1N1v1c2gh~2Qc~9vkwEyt~~-~~ah7mf608~os37K26rtB2lxvFco9re5Qs7SCEieAxriNWN6FGg2DTYCaNLIiezvB2uPO~~-~~9IR9GUzfkmYRDv8m9LF~FOK0tHE03GLsBU7~~-~~1Ol80Q~~-~~ZkT~Mu9BJn9~ZvQFaMX7208JJ~~-~~HAjdHTJF3dXtgM1a9kpk8SwA2CjxQ2N~6~~-~~d0~IfDuqwNiDi4uXFPqkzPIHpQ__~~&Key-Pair-Id=APKAJLOHF5GGSLRBV4ZA		\|url=https://d1wqtxts1xzle7.cloudfront.net/64630392/bioe.12714-libre.pdf?1602188733=&response-content-disposition=inline%3B+filename%3DWhat_is_the_best_age_to_circumcise_A_med.pdf&Expires=1685274798&Signature=fHTGStEInBR4aJERFVi6YaSi84Xt4X2m7Q43zBQIHsDQ6VC1Tzy4mhvJDxumH0JTqBo45iPvE0fty6xejNJZZ9POvPnkHzLxYhjvPQUFANKgSDctUShGvt~HV~-FVSyXU8SbfQHZ9tS72ZbOyRuJc3YGBwAgvDrQ0oZ3aJxUSI28IoFD8raIxeAPtgbBFQ6cd0JNTy6GVRdIPTBzOlKiM4h4R9mwBhh0dfnpsZSGdlpxdIdpe89vDU4cwDLqujE4RPtej7YbTmY3KMrmgI6--dCqBpSLeIr9nJaKKJo-cLSdqLNct7vjn77K9A3--FZ2aTUHtCBVJPdx7P4fJ0cAyA__&Key-Pair-Id=APKAJLOHF5GGSLRBV4ZA
	\|archived=		\|archived=
	\|quote=		\|quote=

WikiModEn2: /* Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision */ Add author link.

2023-05-28T09:35:57Z

Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision: Add author link.

← Older revision		Revision as of 09:35, 28 May 2023
Line 118:		Line 118:
	\|first=		\|first=
	\|init=A		\|init=A
	\|author-link=		\|author-link=Alex Myers
	\|last2=Earp		\|last2=Earp
	\|first2=		\|first2=

WikiModEn2: /* Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision */

2023-05-24T11:07:02Z

Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:07, 24 May 2023
Line 105:		Line 105:
	\|volume=3		\|volume=3
	\|issue=2		\|issue=2
	\|pages=		\|pages=16-8
	\|url=https://muse.jhu.edu/article/44133		\|url=https://muse.jhu.edu/article/44133
	\|quote=		\|quote=

WikiModEn2: Add text and citation.

2023-05-24T11:01:01Z

Add text and citation.

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:01, 24 May 2023
Line 69:		Line 69:

	== Medical ethics and circumcision ==		== Medical ethics and circumcision ==
	Basically, according to the values of medical ethics, the patient has a right of self-determination. In the case of minors, this right is usually exercised by the legal guardians on their behalf, but may only be used for the benefit of the child. An operation that is not medically indicated, such as [[circumcision]], is therefore not within the sphere of influence of [[parental rights]].<ref>{{REFjournal		Basically, according to the values of medical ethics, the patient has a right of self-determination. In the case of minors, this right is usually exercised by the legal guardians on their behalf, but may only be used for the benefit of the child. An operation that is not medically indicated, such as [[circumcision]], is therefore not within the sphere of influence of [[parental rights]].<ref name="aap1995">{{REFjournal
	\|last=Committee on Bioethics		\|last=Committee on Bioethics
	\|etal=no		\|etal=no
Line 78:		Line 78:
	\|location=		\|location=
	\|date=1995-02		\|date=1995-02
	~~\|season=~~
	\|volume=95		\|volume=95
	\|issue=2		\|issue=2
Line 96:		Line 95:

	=== Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision ===		=== Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision ===
	Medical ethics has long recognized that surrogates have only a limited power to consent for others. That consent must be limited to the diagnosis and treatment of disease.		Medical ethics has long recognized that surrogates have only a limited power to consent for others. That consent must be limited to the diagnosis and treatment of disease.<ref name="aap1995" /> The authority of surrogates to grant consent for non-therapeutic circumcision of children has long been questioned.<ref name="hill2003">{{REFjournal
			\|last=Hill
			\|first=
			\|init=G
			\|author-link=George Hill
			\|title=Can anyone authorize the nontherapeutic permanent alteration of a child's body?
			\|journal=The American Journal of Bioethics
			\|date=2003
			\|volume=3
			\|issue=2
			\|pages=
			\|url=https://muse.jhu.edu/article/44133
			\|quote=
			\|pubmedID=14635628
			\|pubmedCID=
			\|DOI=10.1162/152651603766436342
			\|accessdate=2023-05-24
			}}</ref>

	Two ethicists, Myers & Earp (2020), have conducted a detailed review and analysis of the claimed medical benefits of non-therapeutic [[circumcision]]. They have determined that the alleged benefits are not material, so they do not support granting of consent by a surrogate. Moreover, they comment that even the most perfectly executed surgery produces [[trauma]] and harm to the patient. Circumcision also produces tissue loss and loss of function, therefore, circumcision should be performed only after the individual reaches the age of consent and grants consent.<ref name="myers2020">{{REFjournal		Two ethicists, Myers & Earp (2020), have conducted a detailed review and analysis of the claimed medical benefits of non-therapeutic [[circumcision]]. They have determined that the alleged benefits are not material, so they do not support granting of consent by a surrogate. Moreover, they comment that even the most perfectly executed surgery produces [[trauma]] and harm to the patient. Circumcision also produces tissue loss and loss of function, therefore, circumcision should be performed only after the individual reaches the age of consent and grants consent.<ref name="myers2020">{{REFjournal

WikiModEn2: /* Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision */

2023-05-24T10:41:15Z

Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:41, 24 May 2023
Line 96:		Line 96:

	=== Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision ===		=== Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision ===
			Medical ethics has long recognized that surrogates have only a limited power to consent for others. That consent must be limited to the diagnosis and treatment of disease.

	Two ethicists, Myers & Earp (2020), have conducted a detailed review and analysis of the claimed medical benefits of non-therapeutic [[circumcision]]. They have determined that the alleged benefits are not material, so they do not support granting of consent by a surrogate. Moreover, they comment that even the most perfectly executed surgery produces [[trauma]] and harm to the patient. Circumcision also produces tissue loss and loss of function, therefore, circumcision should be performed only after the individual reaches the age of consent and grants consent.<ref name="myers2020">{{REFjournal		Two ethicists, Myers & Earp (2020), have conducted a detailed review and analysis of the claimed medical benefits of non-therapeutic [[circumcision]]. They have determined that the alleged benefits are not material, so they do not support granting of consent by a surrogate. Moreover, they comment that even the most perfectly executed surgery produces [[trauma]] and harm to the patient. Circumcision also produces tissue loss and loss of function, therefore, circumcision should be performed only after the individual reaches the age of consent and grants consent.<ref name="myers2020">{{REFjournal
	\|last=Myers		\|last=Myers

WikiModEn2: /* Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision */ Revise URL.

2023-05-23T20:16:21Z

Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision: Revise URL.

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:16, 23 May 2023
Line 115:		Line 115:
	\|issue=7		\|issue=7
	\|pages=560-72		\|pages=560-72
	\|url=https://~~onlinelibrary~~.~~wiley~~.~~com~~/~~doi/abs/10.1111~~/bioe.12714		\|url=https://d1wqtxts1xzle7.cloudfront.net/64630392/bioe.12714-libre.pdf?1602188733=&response-content-disposition=inline%3B+filename%3DWhat_is_the_best_age_to_circumcise_A_med.pdf&Expires=1684876293&Signature=d1KDXgVkLXAEhblZPrx1j1QmGLHyBG5Hu26oi5RVrbGMxVHo0nLvrJ5fJMIusVa72yX-C6LFaw7dxGUa~ot6ooc9jIXaR6gnA2U98~8PFtWeMwZO8Jzszcl02iF1N1v1c2gh~2Qc~9vkwEyt-ah7mf608~os37K26rtB2lxvFco9re5Qs7SCEieAxriNWN6FGg2DTYCaNLIiezvB2uPO-9IR9GUzfkmYRDv8m9LF~FOK0tHE03GLsBU7-1Ol80Q-ZkT~Mu9BJn9~ZvQFaMX7208JJ-HAjdHTJF3dXtgM1a9kpk8SwA2CjxQ2N~6-d0~IfDuqwNiDi4uXFPqkzPIHpQ__&Key-Pair-Id=APKAJLOHF5GGSLRBV4ZA
	\|archived=		\|archived=
	\|quote=		\|quote=

WikiModEn2: /* Medical ethics and circumcision */ Add section.

2023-05-23T19:17:59Z

Medical ethics and circumcision: Add section.

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:17, 23 May 2023
Line 94:		Line 94:

	The doctors themselves are not allowed to carry out an operation that is not medically indicated if the "patient" — in this case a child who is unable to give consent — cannot give his or her consent. In this case, there would be criminal acts against the child due to unauthorized bodily harm and infliction of damage.		The doctors themselves are not allowed to carry out an operation that is not medically indicated if the "patient" — in this case a child who is unable to give consent — cannot give his or her consent. In this case, there would be criminal acts against the child due to unauthorized bodily harm and infliction of damage.

			=== Mininum age for non-therapeutic circumcision ===
			Two ethicists, Myers & Earp (2020), have conducted a detailed review and analysis of the claimed medical benefits of non-therapeutic [[circumcision]]. They have determined that the alleged benefits are not material, so they do not support granting of consent by a surrogate. Moreover, they comment that even the most perfectly executed surgery produces [[trauma]] and harm to the patient. Circumcision also produces tissue loss and loss of function, therefore, circumcision should be performed only after the individual reaches the age of consent and grants consent.<ref name="myers2020">{{REFjournal
			\|last=Myers
			\|first=
			\|init=A
			\|author-link=
			\|last2=Earp
			\|first2=
			\|init2=BD
			\|author2-link=Brian D. Earp
			\|etal=no
			\|title=What is the best age to circumcise? A medical and ethical analysis
			\|trans-title=
			\|language=
			\|journal=J Biosoc Sci
			\|location=
			\|date=2020-09
			\|volume=34
			\|issue=7
			\|pages=560-72
			\|url=https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/bioe.12714
			\|archived=
			\|quote=
			\|pubmedID=32068898
			\|pubmedCID=
			\|DOI=10.1111/bioe.12714
			\|accessdate=2023-05-23
			}}</ref> Consent by a surrogate for a non-therapeutic circumcision is an unethical practice.


	{{SEEALSO}}		{{SEEALSO}}

WikiModEn2 at 12:48, 23 May 2023

2023-05-23T12:48:23Z

@@ Line 71: / Line 71: @@
 Basically, according to the values of medical ethics, the patient has a right of self-determination. In the case of minors, this right is usually exercised by the legal guardians on their behalf, but may only be used for the benefit of the child. An operation that is not medically indicated, such as [[circumcision]], is therefore not within the sphere of influence of [[parental rights]].<ref>{{REFjournal
   |last=Committee on Bioethics
   |etal=no
   |title=Informed consent, parental permission, and assent in pediatric practice
@@ Line 131: / Line 96: @@
 {{SEEALSO}}
 * [[Jewish medical ethics]]