22,335
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
m
reformatted REFweb + REFnews
According to the National Post, Murray Katz collaborated with [[Neil Pollock]] on creating a so-called "new and innovative technique" for circumcision.<ref>{{REFnews
| last=Owens | first=Anne Marie | coauthors= | url=http://www.pollockclinics.com/circumcision/npost.html | title=Like father, like son There is so much evidence for and against circumcision that making a decision has become almost impossible. In the end, most parents use family tradition or simply trust their instincts | publisher= | work=National Post | quote=Dr. Neil Pollock, a Vancouver-area physician who is also a trained mohel designated to perform ritual Jewish circumcisions, has pioneered a technique with Dr. Murray Katz of Montreal using a four-step approach to pain relief and a piece of equipment that allows for a much quicker operation. | date=22 Jan 2001 | accessdate=2012-10-07
}}</ref> On his website, however, Neil Pollock doesn't seem to offer Katz much credit, and takes most of it for himself.<ref>{{REFweb
| quote=A new approach has recently been developed that allows for a virtually painless and bloodless procedure to be safely performed in under 30 seconds. This technique was developed by Dr. Pollock and is used by few in the medical profession because it is relatively new and more difficult to learn. | url=http://www.pollockclinics.com/circumcision/circumcision-guide.html | title=Parents' Guide to Circumcision | last= | first= | publisher= | website= | date= | accessdate=2011-04-08
}}</ref> This "new technique," which is sold by at least one other doctor, namely [[Pierre Crouse]], is said by Pollock and his associates to be "virtually bloodless," "virtually painless," and "taking under 30 seconds."<ref>{{REFweb
| quote=30 second, virtually bloodless, virtually painless procedure | url=http://www.pollockclinics.com/circumcision/circumcision-index.html | title=Pollock Clinics Infant Circumcision | last= | first= | publisher= | website= | date=2011-04-08 | accessdate=2011-04-08
}}</ref>
Closer inspection reveals that Pollock and Katz aren't doing anything "new"; on his website, Pollock reveals that he uses the Mogen technique, which involves the [[Mogen]] clamp.<ref>{{REFweb
| quote=The technique used by Dr. Pollock is called the Mogen technique. | url=http://www.pollockclinics.com/circumcision/circumcision-guide.html | title=Parents' Guide to Circumcision | last= | first= | publisher= | website= | date= | accessdate=2011-04-08
}}</ref> The Mogen clamp was invented in 1954,<ref name='Reynolds 1996'>{{REFweb
| quote=The Mogen clamp was invented in 1954 by Rabbi Harry Bronstein, a Brooklyn mohel. | url=http://www.circumcisionquotes.com/rdr5.html | title=Use of the Mogen clamp for neonatal circumcision | last= | first= | publisher= | website= | date= | accessdate=2011-04-08
}}</ref> but it is actually one of many successors to the much older, traditional barzel device.<ref>{{REFweb
| quote=The barzel (Hebrew for iron) also known as a mogen (Hebrew for shield) s a slotted shield to... | url=http://www.circumstitions.com/methods.html#barzel | title=Methods of circumcision | last= | first= | publisher= | website=circumstitions.com | date=2011-04-08 | accessdate=2011-04-08
}}</ref>
The website insists that without experience, which it boasts Pollock for having, the methods and techniques he uses could be "potentially dangerous," however the [[Mogen]] clamp has been notorious for glans amputations, even among experienced conductors of circumcision.<ref name='Journal of Perinatology April/May 2002'>{{REFjournal
| last=Taeusch | first=H. William | coauthors=Alma M Martinez, J Colin Partridge, Susan Sniderman, Jennifer Armstrong-Wells, Elena Fuentes-Afflick | title=Pain During Mogen or PlastiBell Circumcision | journal=Journal of Perinatology | volume=22 | issue=3 | pages=214-218 | url=http://www.nature.com/jp/journal/v22/n3/full/7210653a.html | quote=...approximately 10% of the glans of a newborn was amputated (it was reattached surgically) during a Mogen circumcision carried out by two of our most experienced physicians. | pubmedID= | pubmedCID= | DOI= | date=April/May 2002 | accessdate=2011-04-08
}}</ref> Mogen went out of business<ref>{{REFnews
| last=Tagami | first=Ty | coauthors= | url=http://www.ajc.com/news/nation-world/atlanta-lawyer-wins-11-573890.html | title=Atlanta lawyer wins $11 million lawsuit for family in botched circumcision | publisher= | work=The Atlanta Journal-Constitution | quote=The company is going out of business, according to a woman who answered the phone at its Brooklyn headquarters Monday. | date=2010-07-19 | accessdate=2011-04-08
}}</ref> after losing a 10.8 million dollar law suit,<ref>{{REFnews
| last=Tagami | first=Ty | coauthors= | url=http://www.ajc.com/news/nation-world/atlanta-lawyer-wins-11-573890.html | title=Atlanta lawyer wins $11 million lawsuit for family in botched circumcision | publisher= | work=The Atlanta Journal-Constitution | quote=after an infant lost a portion of his penis during an operation with the Mogen clamp, a judge awarded $10.8 million in damages against the company. | date=2010-07-19 | accessdate=2011-04-08
}}</ref> after a mohel<ref>{{REFnews
| last=Tagami | first=Ty | coauthors= | url=http://www.ajc.com/news/nation-world/atlanta-lawyer-wins-11-573890.html | title=Atlanta lawyer wins $11 million lawsuit for family in botched circumcision | publisher= | work=The Atlanta Journal-Constitution | quote=In this case, a New York mohel, or Jewish ritual circumcisor, performed the operation in the baby's home | date=2010-07-19 | accessdate=2011-04-08
}}</ref> severed the end of a baby's glans<ref>{{REFnews
| last=Tagami | first=Ty | coauthors= | url=http://www.ajc.com/news/nation-world/atlanta-lawyer-wins-11-573890.html | title=Atlanta lawyer wins $11 million lawsuit for family in botched circumcision | publisher= | work=The Atlanta Journal-Constitution | quote=The baby in the current case, identified in court documents only as L.G., lost the entire glans, or head, of his penis ... | date=2010-07-19 | accessdate=2011-04-08
}}</ref> using one of their clamps. Mogen claimed that injury was impossible with its use.<ref>{{REFnews
| last=Tagami | first=Ty | coauthors= | url=http://www.ajc.com/news/nation-world/atlanta-lawyer-wins-11-573890.html | title=Atlanta lawyer wins $11 million lawsuit for family in botched circumcision | publisher= | work=The Atlanta Journal-Constitution | quote=The maker of an instrument used in circumcisions claimed that injury was impossible with its use... | date=2010-07-19 | accessdate=2011-04-08
}}</ref> The injury behind a prior lawsuit in Fulton County Superior Court had already put Mogen on notice about the danger of the device.<ref>{{REFnews
| last=Tagami | first=Ty | coauthors= | url=http://www.ajc.com/news/nation-world/atlanta-lawyer-wins-11-573890.html | title=Atlanta lawyer wins $11 million lawsuit for family in botched circumcision | publisher= | work=The Atlanta Journal-Constitution | quote=Attorney David Llewellyn won a similar case in Atlanta last year and the injury behind that prior lawsuit in Fulton County Superior Court put the New York clamp manufacturer on notice about the danger of the device... | date=2010-07-19 | accessdate=2011-04-08
}}</ref>
In a different case, at South Fulton Medical Center, another law suit was won in 2009.<ref>{{REFnews
| last=Tagami | first=Ty | coauthors= | url=http://www.ajc.com/news/nation-world/atlanta-lawyer-wins-11-573890.html | title=Atlanta lawyer wins $11 million lawsuit for family in botched circumcision | publisher= | work=The Atlanta Journal-Constitution | quote=Llewellyn won another circumcision case in 2009 over an operation at South Fulton Medical Center. | date=2010-07-19 | accessdate=2011-04-08
}}</ref> In that case, a child lost a third of his glans, and the plaintiffs were awarded 2.3 million dollars.<ref>{{REFnews
| last=Tagami | first=Ty | coauthors= | url=http://www.ajc.com/news/nation-world/atlanta-lawyer-wins-11-573890.html | title=Atlanta lawyer wins $11 million lawsuit for family in botched circumcision | publisher= | work=The Atlanta Journal-Constitution | quote=The jury found that both the pediatrician and the physician who performed the circumcision were negligent, and awarded $2.3 million to the plaintiffs. | date=2010-07-19 | accessdate=2011-04-08
}}</ref>