15,259
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
==Observations==
The non-therapeutic circumcision industry in the United States produces more than $2 billion annually.<ref name="bollinger2012">{{REFweb
|url=https://www.academia.edu/6442587/High_Cost_of_Circumcision_3.6_Billion_Annually
|title=High Cost of Circumcision: $3.6 Billion Annually
|last=Bollinger
|first=Dan
|author-link=Dan Bollinger
|publisher=Academia
|website=https://www.academia.edu
|date=2012
|accessdate=2021-11-12
|format=
|quote=As the saying goes, follow the money. Now you know why neither the [[American Academy of Pediatrics]], American Medical Association, [[American Academy of Family Physicians]], or the [[American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists| American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists]] haven’t condemned this unnecessary surgery, and why their physician members are quick to recommend the procedure to expectant parents.
}}</ref> [[Third-party payment]] is a major support to the performance of this medically-unnecessary surgery. If parents could not grant consent for non-therapeutic circumcision, then no one could grant consent for the non-therapeutic circumcision of a child, so the $2 billion annual business would collapse. The American [[Medical trade association| medical trade associations]], more than those of other nations, have been unwilling to recognize the child's right to [[physical integrity]], to security of the person, and the right to personal autonomy.
* {{REFjournal
|last=Freeman
|init=MD
|authorlink=
|date=1999
|title=A child's right to circumcision
|journal=BJU Int
|volume=83
|issue=Suppl. 1
|pages=74-78
|pubmedID=10349417
|DOI=10.1046/j.1464-410x.1999.0830s1074.x
}}
→The emerging consensus on surrogate consent for non-therapeutic newborn, infant, and child circumcision: Update URL.
# unjustified differential treatment of children of the same sex,<br>
# unjustified differential treatment of children of different sexes,<br>
# problems with child safeguarding, and (8) # problems with regulation and training. ,<br># an unjustified presumption of lawfulness of NPC of minors , and<br> #) failure adequately to address recent case law.<ref name="lempert2022">{{REFjournal
|last=Lempert
|first=Antony
== Journal of Medical Ethics ==
<!--
===JME symposium on circumcision, June 2004===
The ''Journal of Medical Ethics'' published a "symposium on circumcision" in its June 2004 issue.<ref name="symposium2004">{{REFjournal
|pubmedCID=1733850
}}</ref>
-->
===Journal of Medical Ethics circumcision issue, July 2013===
The ''Journal of Medical Ethics'' devoted the entire July 2013 issue to the controversial issue of non-therapeutic circumcision of male children.<ref>{{REFjournal
Regardless of these issues, the unethical general practice of the medical community in the United States is to receive surrogate informed consent or permission from parents or legal guardians for non-therapeutic circumcision of children.<ref name="povenmire"/><ref name="conundrum" />
== The emerging consensus on surrogate consent for non-therapeutic newborn, infant, and child circumcision ==
|issue=2
|pages=16-8
|url=https://musewww.jhuresearchgate.edunet/articleprofile/44133George-Hill-3/publication/371599857_Can_Anyone_Authorize_the_Nontherapeutic_Permanent_Alteration_of_a_Child's_Body/links/648b8819c41fb852dd0949be/Can-Anyone-Authorize-the-Nontherapeutic-Permanent-Alteration-of-a-Childs-Body.pdf
|quote=
|pubmedID=14635628
|pubmedCID=
|DOI=10.1162/152651603766436342
|format=PDF |accessdate=2023-0507-2711
}}</ref>
|issue=7
|pages=645-63
|url=https://d1wqtxts1xzle7www.cloudfrontresearchgate.net/64630392profile/bioe.12714Brian-Earp-2/publication/337720859_What_Is_the_Best_Age_to_Circumcise_A_Medical_and_Ethical_Analysis/links/5f815f61a6fdccfd7b555395/What-libre.pdf?1602188733=&responseIs-contentthe-disposition=inline%3B+filename%3DWhat_is_the_best_age_to_circumcise_A_med.pdf&Expires=1685274798&Signature=fHTGStEInBR4aJERFVi6YaSi84Xt4X2m7Q43zBQIHsDQ6VC1Tzy4mhvJDxumH0JTqBo45iPvE0fty6xejNJZZ9POvPnkHzLxYhjvPQUFANKgSDctUShGvt~HV~Best-FVSyXU8SbfQHZ9tS72ZbOyRuJc3YGBwAgvDrQ0oZ3aJxUSI28IoFD8raIxeAPtgbBFQ6cd0JNTy6GVRdIPTBzOlKiM4h4R9mwBhh0dfnpsZSGdlpxdIdpe89vDU4cwDLqujE4RPtej7YbTmY3KMrmgI6Age-to-dCqBpSLeIr9nJaKKJoCircumcise-cLSdqLNct7vjn77K9A3A-Medical-FZ2aTUHtCBVJPdx7P4fJ0cAyA__&Keyand-PairEthical-Id=APKAJLOHF5GGSLRBV4ZAAnalysis.pdf
|archived=
|quote=Based on a careful consideration of the relevant evidence, arguments and counterarguments, we conclude that medically unnecessary penile circumcision-like other medically unnecessary genital procedures, such as 'cosmetic' labiaplasty-should not be performed on individuals who are too young (or otherwise unable) to provide meaningful consent to the procedure.
|date=2013
}}</ref> if a court should accept Adler's arguments.
== Observations ==
The non-therapeutic circumcision industry in the United States produces more than $2 billion annually.<ref name="bollinger2012">{{REFweb
|url=https://www.academia.edu/6442587/High_Cost_of_Circumcision_3.6_Billion_Annually
|title=High Cost of Circumcision: $3.6 Billion Annually
|last=Bollinger
|first=Dan
|author-link=Dan Bollinger
|publisher=Academia
|website=https://www.academia.edu
|date=2012
|accessdate=2021-11-12
|format=
|quote=As the saying goes, follow the money. Now you know why neither the [[American Academy of Pediatrics]], American Medical Association, [[American Academy of Family Physicians]], or the [[American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists| American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists]] haven’t condemned this unnecessary surgery, and why their physician members are quick to recommend the procedure to expectant parents.
}}</ref> [[Third-party payment]] is a major support to the performance of this medically-unnecessary surgery. If parents could not grant consent for non-therapeutic circumcision, then no one could grant consent for the non-therapeutic circumcision of a child, so the $2 billion annual business would collapse. The American [[Medical trade association| medical trade associations]], more than those of other nations, have been unwilling to recognize the child's right to [[physical integrity]], to security of the person, and the right to personal autonomy.
{{SEEALSO}}
{{LINKS}}
* {{REFjournal
|last=Goodman