German Circumcision Act - Roll-call vote
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Main article: German Circumcision Act
This sub-article lists the voting behavior of the German Bundestag members from 2012-12-12 on the German Circumcision Act in detail.[1]
| Yes | = Consent that boys in Germany should no longer have the right to physical integrity. |
| No | = These MPs advocate that boys in Germany should retain the right to physical integrity. |
Contents
Circumcision, Federal Government Bill
Draft law by the federal government on the extent of personal care in the event of a male circumcision (printed matters 17/11295, 17/11800, and 17/11814)
Voting by parties
On 2012-12-12, the German Bundestag voted on the German Circumcision Act as follows:
| Party | Member | Yes | No | Abstained | Didn't vote | % Yes | % No | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total | 620 | 434 | 100 | 46 | 40 | 70,00 % | 16,13 % | |
| CDU/CSU | 237 | 215 | 3 | 3 | 16 | 90,72 % | 1,27 % | |
| CDU | 193 | 177 | 3 | 3 | 9 | 92,19 % | 1,55 % | |
| CSU | 44 | 37 | 0 | 0 | 7 | 84,09 % | 0,0 % | |
| SPD | 146 | 89 | 32 | 16 | 9 | 60,96 % | 21,92 % | |
| FDP | 93 | 79 | 5 | 2 | 7 | 84,95 % | 5,38 % | |
| LEFT | 76 | 17 | 44 | 10 | 5 | 22,37 % | 57,89 % | |
| GREENS | 68 | 34 | 16 | 15 | 3 | 50,00 % | 23,53 % | |
Voting by MPs
°| Name | Party | State | Vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Altmaier, Peter | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saarland | Didn't vote |
| Bareiß, Thomas | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Barthle, Norbert | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Baumann, Günter | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Yes |
| Beck, Ernst-Reinhard | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Behrens, Manfred | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony-Anhalt | Yes |
| Bellmann, Veronika | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Yes |
| Bergner, Dr. Christoph | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony-Anhalt | Yes |
| Beyer, Peter | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Bilger, Steffen | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Binninger, Clemens | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Bleser, Peter | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Böhmer, Prof. Dr. Maria | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Börnsen, Wolfgang | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Schleswig-Holstein | Didn't vote |
| Bosbach, Wolfgang | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Brackmann, Norbert | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Schleswig-Holstein | Yes |
| Brähmig, Klaus | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Yes |
| Brand, Michael | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hesse | Yes |
| Brandt, Helmut | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Brauksiepe, Dr. Ralf | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Braun, Prof. Dr. Helge | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hesse | Yes |
| Brehmer, Heike | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony-Anhalt | Yes |
| Brinkhaus, Ralph | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Caesar, Cajus | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Connemann, Gitta | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Dörflinger, Thomas | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Dött, Marie-Luise | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Feist, Dr. Thomas | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Yes |
| Ferlemann, Enak | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Fischbach, Ingrid | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Fischer, Axel E. | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Fischer, Dirk | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hamburg | Yes |
| Fischer, Hartwig | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Flachsbarth, Dr. Maria | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Flosbach, Klaus-Peter | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Fritz, Erich G. | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Fuchs, Dr. Michael | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Fuchtel, Hans-Joachim | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Funk, Alexander | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saarland | Yes |
| Gädechens, Ingo | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Schleswig-Holstein | Yes |
| Gebhart, Dr. Thomas | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Gerig, Alois | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Gienger, Eberhard | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Götz, Peter | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Granold, Ute | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Grindel, Reinhard | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Didn't vote |
| Gröhe, Hermann | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Grosse-Brömer, Michael | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Grübel, Markus | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Grund, Manfred | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Thuringia | Yes |
| Grütters, Monika | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Berlin | Yes |
| Gutting, Olav | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | No |
| Harbarth, Dr. Stephan | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Hardt, Jürgen | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Heider, Dr. Matthias | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Heiderich, Helmut | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hesse | Yes |
| Heil, Mechthild | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Heinen-Esser, Ursula | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Heinrich, Frank | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Yes |
| Henke, Rudolf | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Hennrich, Michael | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Heveling, Ansgar | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Hintze, Peter | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Hirte, Christian | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Thuringia | Yes |
| Hochbaum, Robert | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Yes |
| Holzenkamp, Franz-Josef | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Hörster, Joachim | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Hübinger, Anette | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saarland | Yes |
| Hüppe, Hubert | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Jarzombek, Thomas | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Jasper, Dieter | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Jung, Andreas | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Jung, Dr. Franz Josef | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hesse | Yes |
| Jüttner, Dr. Egon | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | No |
| Kammer, Hans-Werner | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Kampeter, Steffen | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Kaster, Bernhard | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Kauder, Siegfried | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Kauder, Volker | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Kaufmann, Dr. Stefan | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Kiesewetter, Roderich | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Klaeden, Eckart von | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Klamt, Ewa | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Klein, Volkmar | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Klimke, Jürgen | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hamburg | Yes |
| Knoerig, Axel | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Koeppen, Jens | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Brandenburg | Yes |
| Kolbe, Manfred | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Didn't vote |
| Koschorrek, Dr. Rolf | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Schleswig-Holstein | Yes |
| Kossendey, Thomas | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Kretschmer, Michael | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Yes |
| Krichbaum, Gunther | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Krings, Dr. Günter | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Kruse, Rüdiger | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hamburg | Yes |
| Kudla, Bettina | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Yes |
| Kues, Dr. Hermann | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Lach, Günter | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Lamers, Prof. h.c. Dr. Karl A. | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Didn't vote |
| Lämmel, Andreas G. | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Yes |
| Lammert, Prof. Dr. Norbert | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Landgraf, Katharina | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Yes |
| Leyen, Dr. Ursula von der | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Liebing, Ingbert | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Schleswig-Holstein | Yes |
| Lietz, Matthias | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania | Yes |
| Linnemann, Dr. Carsten | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Lips, Patricia | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hesse | Yes |
| Luczak, Dr. Jan-Marco | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Berlin | Yes |
| Luther, Dr. Michael | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Didn't vote |
| Maag, Karin | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Maizière, Dr. Thomas de | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Yes |
| Marwitz, Hans-Georg von der | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Brandenburg | Yes |
| Mattfeldt, Andreas | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | No |
| Meister, Dr. Michael | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hesse | Yes |
| Merkel, Dr. Angela | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania | Yes |
| Michalk, Maria | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Yes |
| Middelberg, Dr. Mathias | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Mißfelder, Philipp | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Monstadt, Dietrich | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania | Yes |
| Murmann, Dr. Philipp | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Schleswig-Holstein | Yes |
| Neumann, Bernd | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Bremen | Yes |
| Noll, Michaela | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Otte, Henning | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Paul, Dr. Michael | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Didn't vote |
| Pawelski, Rita | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Petzold, Ulrich | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony-Anhalt | Yes |
| Pfeiffer, Dr. Joachim | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Pfeiffer, Sibylle | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hesse | Yes |
| Philipp, Beatrix | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Pofalla, Ronald | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Poland, Christoph | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania | Yes |
| Polenz, Ruprecht | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Pols, Eckhard | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Abstained |
| Rachel, Thomas | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Rehberg, Eckhardt | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania | Yes |
| Reiche, Katherina | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Brandenburg | Yes |
| Riebsamen, Lothar | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Rief, Josef | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Riegert, Klaus | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Riesenhuber, Prof. Dr. Heinz | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hesse | Yes |
| Röring, Johannes | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Röttgen, Dr. Norbert | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Rüddel, Erwin | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Schäfer, Anita | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Schäuble, Dr. Wolfgang | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Didn't vote |
| Schavan, Annette | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Schiewerling, Karl | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Schindler, Norbert | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Rhineland-Palatinate | Abstained |
| Schipanski, Tankred | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Thuringia | Yes |
| Schirmbeck, Georg | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Schnieder, Patrick | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Schockenhoff, Dr. Andreas | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Schön, Nadine | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saarland | Yes |
| Schröder, Dr. Kristina | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hesse | Yes |
| Schröder, Dr. Ole | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Schleswig-Holstein | Yes |
| Schulte-Drüggelte, Bernhard | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Abstained |
| Schummer, Uwe | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Schuster, Armin | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Seif, Detlef | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Selle, Johannes | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Thuringia | Yes |
| Sendker, Reinhold | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Sensburg, Prof. Dr. Patrick | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Siebert, Bernd | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hesse | Yes |
| Spahn, Jens | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Stauche, Carola | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Thuringia | Yes |
| Steffel, Dr. Frank | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Berlin | Yes |
| Steinbach, Erika | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hesse | Yes |
| Stetten, Christian Freiherr von | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Stier, Dieter | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony-Anhalt | Yes |
| Storjohann, Gero | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Schleswig-Holstein | Yes |
| Strenz, Karin | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania | Yes |
| Strobl, Thomas | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Strothmann, Lena | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Stübgen, Michael | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Brandenburg | Yes |
| Tauber, Dr. Peter | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hesse | Yes |
| Tillmann, Antje | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Thuringia | Yes |
| Vaatz, Arnold | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Yes |
| Vogel, Volkmar | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Thuringia | Yes |
| Vogelsang, Stefanie | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Berlin | Yes |
| Voßhoff, Andrea Astrid | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Brandenburg | Yes |
| Wadephul, Dr. Johann | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Schleswig-Holstein | Didn't vote |
| Wanderwitz, Marco | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Saxony | Yes |
| Wegner, Kai | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Berlin | Yes |
| Weinberg, Marcus | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hamburg | Yes |
| Weiß, Peter | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Weiss, Sabine | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Wellenreuther, Ingo | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Wellmann, Karl-Georg | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Berlin | Yes |
| Wichtel, Peter | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hesse | Yes |
| Widmann-Mauz, Annette | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Willsch, Klaus-Peter | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hesse | Yes |
| Winkelmeier-Becker, Elisabeth | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Zimmer, Prof. Dr. Matthias | CDU/CSU (CDU) | Hesse | Yes |
| Zylajew, Willi | CDU/CSU (CDU) | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Aigner, Ilse | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Didn't vote |
| Aumer, Peter | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Bär, Dorothee | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Didn't vote |
| Brandl, Dr. Reinhard | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Dobrindt, Alexander | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Frankenhauser, Herbert | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Didn't vote |
| Friedrich, Dr. Hans-Peter | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Frieser, Michael | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Gauweiler, Dr. Peter | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Didn't vote |
| Geis, Norbert | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Glos, Michael | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Didn't vote |
| Göppel, Josef | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Didn't vote |
| Götzer, Dr. Wolfgang | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Hahn, Florian | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Hasselfeldt, Gerda | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Hinsken, Ernst | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Holmeier, Karl | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Kalb, Bartholomäus | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Karl, Alois | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Koschyk, Hartmut | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Lange, Ulrich | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Lehmer, Dr. Max | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Lehrieder, Paul | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Ludwig, Daniela | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Mayer, Stephan | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Michelbach, Dr. h. c. Hans | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Mortler, Marlene | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Müller, Dr. Gerd | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Müller, Stefan | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Nüßlein, Dr. iur. Georg | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Obermeier, Franz | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Oswald, Eduard | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Ramsauer, Dr. Peter | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Didn't vote |
| Ruck, Dr. Christian | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Rupprecht, Albert | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Scheuer, Andreas | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Schmidt, Christian | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Silberhorn, Thomas | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Singhammer, Johannes | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Stracke, Stephan | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Straubinger, Max | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Uhl, Dr. Hans-Peter | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Wöhrl, Dagmar G. | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Zöller, Wolfgang | CDU/CSU (CSU) | Bavaria | Yes |
| Arndt-Brauer, Ingrid | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Arnold, Rainer | SPD | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Barchmann, Heinz-Joachim | SPD | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Barnett, Doris | SPD | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Bartels, Dr. Hans-Peter | SPD | Schleswig-Holstein | Yes |
| Barthel, Klaus | SPD | Bavaria | Abstained |
| Bartol, Sören | SPD | Hesse | Yes |
| Bas, Bärbel | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Bätzing-Lichtenthäler, Sabine | SPD | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Becker, Dirk | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Beckmeyer, Uwe | SPD | Bremen | Yes |
| Binding, Lothar | SPD | Baden-Wuerttemberg | No |
| Bollmann, Gerd | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Brandner, Klaus | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Brase, Willi | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Brinkmann, Bernhard | SPD | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Bulmahn, Dr. h.c. Edelgard | SPD | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Bülow, Marco | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Burchardt, Ulla | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Burkert, Martin | SPD | Bavaria | Yes |
| Crone, Petra | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Danckert, Prof. Dr. Peter | SPD | Brandenburg | Abstained |
| Dörmann, Martin | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Drobinski-Weiß, Elvira | SPD | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Edathy, Sebastian | SPD | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Egloff, Ingo | SPD | Hamburg | No |
| Ehrmann, Siegmund | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Erler, Dr. h.c. Gernot | SPD | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Ernstberger, Petra | SPD | Bavaria | Abstained |
| Evers-Meyer, Karin | SPD | Lower Saxony | No |
| Ferner, Elke | SPD | Saarland | No |
| Fograscher, Gabriele | SPD | Bavaria | Yes |
| Franke, Dr. Edgar | SPD | Hesse | Abstained |
| Freitag, Dagmar | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Gabriel, Sigmar | SPD | Lower Saxony | Didn't vote |
| Gerdes, Michael | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Gerster, Martin | SPD | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Gleicke, Iris | SPD | Thuringia | Yes |
| Gloser, Günter | SPD | Bavaria | Yes |
| Gottschalck, Ulrike | SPD | Hesse | Didn't vote |
| Graf, Angelika | SPD | Bavaria | Abstained |
| Griese, Kerstin | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Groneberg, Gabriele | SPD | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Groß, Michael | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Abstained |
| Gunkel, Wolfgang | SPD | Saxony | Yes |
| Hacker, Hans-Joachim | SPD | Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania | Yes |
| Hagedorn, Bettina | SPD | Schleswig-Holstein | Yes |
| Hagemann, Klaus | SPD | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Hartmann, Michael | SPD | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Heil, Hubertus | SPD | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Hellmich, Wolfgang | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Hempelmann, Rolf | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Abstained |
| Hendricks, Dr. Barbara | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Herzog, Gustav | SPD | Rhineland-Palatinate | Abstained |
| Hiller-Ohm, Gabriele | SPD | Schleswig-Holstein | No |
| Hinz, Petra | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Hofmann, Frank | SPD | Bavaria | Didn't vote |
| Högl, Dr. Eva | SPD | Berlin | Yes |
| Humme, Christel | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Juratovic, Josip | SPD | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Kaczmarek, Oliver | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Kahrs, Johannes | SPD | Hamburg | Yes |
| Kastner, Dr. h. c. Susanne | SPD | Bavaria | Yes |
| Kelber, Ulrich | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Klingbeil, Lars | SPD | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Klose, Hans-Ulrich | SPD | Hamburg | Yes |
| Kofler, Dr. Bärbel | SPD | Bavaria | Yes |
| Kolbe, Daniela | SPD | Saxony | Yes |
| Körper, Fritz Rudolf | SPD | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Kramme, Anette | SPD | Bavaria | Didn't vote |
| Krüger-Leißner, Angelika | SPD | Brandenburg | No |
| Kumpf, Ute | SPD | Baden-Wuerttemberg | No |
| Lambrecht, Christine | SPD | Hesse | Yes |
| Lange, Christian | SPD | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Lauterbach, Dr. Karl | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Lemme, Steffen-Claudio | SPD | Thuringia | No |
| Lischka, Burkhard | SPD | Saxony-Anhalt | Yes |
| Lösekrug-Möller, Gabriele | SPD | Lower Saxony | Abstained |
| Lühmann, Kirsten | SPD | Lower Saxony | No |
| Marks, Caren | SPD | Lower Saxony | No |
| Mast, Katja | SPD | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Mattheis, Hilde | SPD | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Abstained |
| Merkel, Petra | SPD | Berlin | Yes |
| Meßmer, Ullrich | SPD | Hesse | Abstained |
| Miersch, Dr. Matthias | SPD | Lower Saxony | Abstained |
| Müntefering, Franz | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Mützenich, Dr. Rolf | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Nahles, Andrea | SPD | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
| Nietan, Dietmar | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Nink, Manfred | SPD | Rhineland-Palatinate | Didn't vote |
| Oppermann, Thomas | SPD | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Ortel, Holger | SPD | Lower Saxony | Didn't vote |
| Özoguz, Aydan | SPD | Hamburg | Yes |
| Paula, Heinz | SPD | Bavaria | Yes |
| Pflug, Johannes | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Poß, Joachim | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Priesmeier, Dr. Wilhelm | SPD | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Pronold, Florian | SPD | Bavaria | Yes |
| Raabe, Dr. Sascha | SPD | Hesse | Abstained |
| Rawert, Mechthild | SPD | Berlin | Yes |
| Rebmann, Stefan | SPD | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Reichenbach, Gerold | SPD | Hesse | No |
| Reimann, Dr. Carola | SPD | Lower Saxony | Abstained |
| Rix, Sönke | SPD | Schleswig-Holstein | Yes |
| Röspel, René | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Rossmann, Dr. Ernst Dieter | SPD | Schleswig-Holstein | Yes |
| Roth, Karin | SPD | Baden-Wuerttemberg | No |
| Roth, Michael | SPD | Hesse | Yes |
| Rupprecht, Marlene | SPD | Bavaria | No |
| Sawade, Annette | SPD | Baden-Wuerttemberg | No |
| Schaaf, Anton | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Schäfer, Axel | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Didn't vote |
| Scheelen, Bernd | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Schieder, Marianne | SPD | Bavaria | Yes |
| Schieder, Werner | SPD | Bavaria | Yes |
| Schmidt, Silvia | SPD | Saxony-Anhalt | Didn't vote |
| Schmidt, Ulla | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Schneider, Carsten | SPD | Thuringia | Abstained |
| Schreiner, Ottmar | SPD | Saarland | Yes |
| Schulz, Swen | SPD | Berlin | Yes |
| Schurer, Ewald | SPD | Bavaria | No |
| Schwabe, Frank | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Schwanholz, Dr. Martin | SPD | Lower Saxony | Abstained |
| Schwanitz, Rolf | SPD | Saxony | No |
| Schwartze, Stefan | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Schwarzelühr-Sutter, Rita | SPD | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Sieling, Dr. Carsten | SPD | Bremen | No |
| Steffen, Sonja | SPD | Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania | Yes |
| Steinbrück, Peer | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Steinmeier, Dr. Frank-Walter | SPD | Brandenburg | Yes |
| Strässer, Christoph | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Tack, Kerstin | SPD | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Thierse, Dr. h. c. Wolfgang | SPD | Berlin | Yes |
| Thönnes, Franz | SPD | Schleswig-Holstein | Yes |
| Tiefensee, Wolfgang | SPD | Saxony | Yes |
| Veit, Rüdiger | SPD | Hesse | No |
| Vogt, Ute | SPD | Baden-Wuerttemberg | No |
| Volkmer, Dr. Marlies | SPD | Saxony | No |
| Wicklein, Andrea | SPD | Brandenburg | No |
| Wieczorek-Zeul, Heidemarie | SPD | Hesse | Yes |
| Wiefelspütz, Dr. Dieter | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Wolff, Waltraud | SPD | Saxony-Anhalt | Yes |
| Zapf, Uta | SPD | Hesse | Didn't vote |
| Ziegler, Dagmar | SPD | Brandenburg | No |
| Zöllmer, Manfred | SPD | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Zypries, Brigitte | SPD | Hesse | Yes |
| Aken, Jan van | LEFT | Hamburg | Yes |
| Alpers, Agnes | LEFT | Bremen | No |
| Bartsch, Dr. Dietmar | LEFT | Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania | Abstained |
| Behrens, Herbert | LEFT | Lower Saxony | No |
| Binder, Karin | LEFT | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Didn't vote |
| Birkwald, Matthias W. | LEFT | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Bluhm, Heidrun | LEFT | Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania | Didn't vote |
| Bockhahn, Steffen | LEFT | Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania | No |
| Buchholz, Christine | LEFT | Hesse | Yes |
| Bulling-Schröter, Eva | LEFT | Bavaria | Abstained |
| Bunge, Dr. Martina | LEFT | Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania | Yes |
| Claus, Roland | LEFT | Saxony-Anhalt | Yes |
| Dagdelen, Sevim | LEFT | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Dehm, Dr. Diether | LEFT | Lower Saxony | No |
| Dittrich, Heidrun | LEFT | Lower Saxony | No |
| Dreibus, Werner | LEFT | Hesse | Yes |
| Enkelmann, Dr. Dagmar | LEFT | Brandenburg | No |
| Ernst, Klaus | LEFT | Bavaria | No |
| Gehrcke, Wolfgang | LEFT | Hesse | No |
| Gohlke, Nicole | LEFT | Bavaria | Yes |
| Golze, Diana | LEFT | Brandenburg | No |
| Groth, Annette | LEFT | Baden-Wuerttemberg | No |
| Gysi, Dr. Gregor | LEFT | Berlin | Yes |
| Hänsel, Heike | LEFT | Baden-Wuerttemberg | No |
| Hein, Dr. Rosemarie | LEFT | Saxony-Anhalt | Yes |
| Höger, Inge | LEFT | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Höll, Dr. Barbara | LEFT | Saxony | No |
| Hunko, Andrej | LEFT | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Jelpke, Ulla | LEFT | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Jochimsen, Dr. Lukrezia | LEFT | Thuringia | Yes |
| Kipping, Katja | LEFT | Saxony | No |
| Koch, Harald | LEFT | Saxony-Anhalt | Yes |
| Korte, Jan | LEFT | Saxony-Anhalt | No |
| Krellmann, Jutta | LEFT | Lower Saxony | Abstained |
| Kunert, Katrin | LEFT | Saxony-Anhalt | No |
| Lay, Caren | LEFT | Saxony | Yes |
| Leidig, Sabine | LEFT | Hesse | No |
| Lenkert, Ralph | LEFT | Thuringia | No |
| Leutert, Michael | LEFT | Saxony | No |
| Liebich, Stefan | LEFT | Berlin | No |
| Lötzer, Ulla | LEFT | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Lötzsch, Dr. Gesine | LEFT | Berlin | Abstained |
| Lutze, Thomas | LEFT | Saarland | No |
| Maurer, Ulrich | LEFT | Baden-Wuerttemberg | No |
| Menzner, Dorothée | LEFT | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Möhring, Cornelia | LEFT | Schleswig-Holstein | No |
| Möller, Kornelia | LEFT | Bavaria | Abstained |
| Movassat, Niema | LEFT | North Rhine-Westphalia | Abstained |
| Nešković, Wolfgang | LEFT | Brandenburg | No |
| Nord, Thomas | LEFT | Brandenburg | No |
| Pau, Petra | LEFT | Berlin | Yes |
| Petermann, Jens | LEFT | Thuringia | No |
| Pitterle, Richard | LEFT | Baden-Wuerttemberg | No |
| Ploetz, Yvonne | LEFT | Saarland | No |
| Remmers, Ingrid Lieselotte | LEFT | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Schäfer, Paul | LEFT | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Schlecht, Michael | LEFT | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Seifert, Dr. Ilja | LEFT | Saxony | Didn't vote |
| Senger-Schäfer, Kathrin | LEFT | Rhineland-Palatinate | No |
| Sharma, Raju | LEFT | Schleswig-Holstein | No |
| Sitte, Dr. Petra | LEFT | Saxony-Anhalt | No |
| Steinke, Kersten | LEFT | Thuringia | No |
| Stüber, Sabine Ursula | LEFT | Brandenburg | No |
| Süßmair, Alexander | LEFT | Bavaria | No |
| Tackmann, Dr. Kirsten | LEFT | Brandenburg | No |
| Tempel, Frank | LEFT | Thuringia | No |
| Troost, Dr. Axel | LEFT | Saxony | Yes |
| Ulrich, Alexander | LEFT | Rhineland-Palatinate | Abstained |
| Vogler, Kathrin | LEFT | North Rhine-Westphalia | Abstained |
| Voß, Johanna | LEFT | Lower Saxony | No |
| Wagenknecht, Dr. Sahra | LEFT | North Rhine-Westphalia | Didn't vote |
| Wawzyniak, Halina | LEFT | Berlin | No |
| Weinberg, Harald | LEFT | Bavaria | Abstained |
| Werner, Katrin | LEFT | Rhineland-Palatinate | Didn't vote |
| Wunderlich, Jörn | LEFT | Saxony | No |
| Zimmermann, Sabine | LEFT | Saxony | Abstained |
| Andreae, Kerstin | GREENS | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Beck, Marieluise | GREENS | Bremen | Yes |
| Beck, Volker | GREENS | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Behm, Cornelia | GREENS | Brandenburg | Yes |
| Bender, Birgitt | GREENS | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Brugger, Agnieszka | GREENS | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Abstained |
| Cramon-Taubadel, Viola von | GREENS | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Deligöz, Ekin | GREENS | Bavaria | Yes |
| Dörner, Katja | GREENS | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Ebner, Harald | GREENS | Baden-Wuerttemberg | No |
| Fell, Hans-Josef | GREENS | Bavaria | Yes |
| Gambke, Dr. Thomas | GREENS | Bavaria | Yes |
| Gehring, Kai | GREENS | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Göring-Eckardt, Katrin | GREENS | Thuringia | Yes |
| Haßelmann, Britta | GREENS | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Herlitzius, Bettina | GREENS | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Hinz, Priska | GREENS | Hesse | Yes |
| Hofreiter, Dr. Anton | GREENS | Bavaria | Abstained |
| Höhn, Bärbel | GREENS | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Hönlinger, Ingrid | GREENS | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Abstained |
| Hoppe, Thilo | GREENS | Lower Saxony | Abstained |
| Kekeritz, Uwe | GREENS | Bavaria | No |
| Keul, Katja | GREENS | Lower Saxony | No |
| Kilic, Memet | GREENS | Baden-Wuerttemberg | No |
| Kindler, Sven-Christian | GREENS | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Klein-Schmeink, Maria | GREENS | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Koczy, Ute | GREENS | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Koenigs, Tom | GREENS | Hesse | Yes |
| Kotting-Uhl, Sylvia | GREENS | Baden-Wuerttemberg | No |
| Krischer, Oliver | GREENS | North Rhine-Westphalia | Abstained |
| Krumwiede, Agnes | GREENS | Bavaria | No |
| Kuhn, Fritz | GREENS | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Kühn, Stephan | GREENS | Saxony | Didn't vote |
| Künast, Renate | GREENS | Berlin | Yes |
| Kurth, Markus | GREENS | North Rhine-Westphalia | Abstained |
| Kurth, Undine | GREENS | Saxony-Anhalt | Abstained |
| Lazar, Monika | GREENS | Saxony | No |
| Lindner, Dr. Tobias | GREENS | Rhineland-Palatinate | Abstained |
| Maisch, Nicole | GREENS | Hesse | Yes |
| Montag, Jerzy | GREENS | Bavaria | Yes |
| Müller, Kerstin | GREENS | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Müller-Gemmeke, Beate | GREENS | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Notz, Dr. Konstantin von | GREENS | Schleswig-Holstein | Yes |
| Nouripour, Omid | GREENS | Hesse | Yes |
| Ostendorff, Friedrich | GREENS | North Rhine-Westphalia | No |
| Ott, Dr. Hermann E. | GREENS | North Rhine-Westphalia | Yes |
| Paus, Lisa | GREENS | Berlin | Yes |
| Pothmer, Brigitte | GREENS | Lower Saxony | Yes |
| Rößner, Tabea | GREENS | Rhineland-Palatinate | Abstained |
| Roth, Claudia | GREENS | Bavaria | Yes |
| Sager, Krista | GREENS | Hamburg | Abstained |
| Sarrazin, Manuel | GREENS | Hamburg | Yes |
| Scharfenberg, Elisabeth | GREENS | Bavaria | Yes |
| Schick, Dr. Gerhard | GREENS | Baden-Wuerttemberg | Yes |
| Schmidt, Dr. Frithjof | GREENS | North Rhine-Westphalia | Didn't vote |
| Schneider, Ulrich | GREENS | Baden-Wuerttemberg | No |
| Steiner, Dorothea | GREENS | Lower Saxony | No |
| Strengmann-Kuhn, Dr. Wolfgang | GREENS | Hesse | Abstained |
| Ströbele, Hans-Christian | GREENS | Berlin | Abstained |
| Terpe, Dr. Harald | GREENS | Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania | Didn't vote |
| Tressel, Markus | GREENS | Saarland | Yes |
| Trittin, Jürgen | GREENS | Lower Saxony | Abstained |
| Wagner, Arfst | GREENS | Schleswig-Holstein | Abstained |
| Wagner, Daniela | GREENS | Hesse | Yes |
| Walter-Rosenheimer, Beate | GREENS | Bavaria | Abstained |
| Wieland, Wolfgang | GREENS | Berlin | Yes |
| Wilms, Dr. Valerie | GREENS | Schleswig-Holstein | No |
| Winkler, Josef Philip | GREENS | Rhineland-Palatinate | Yes |
References
- ↑
(12 December 2012). Namentliche Abstimmung
[Roll-call vote] (German), Deutscher Bundestag. Retrieved 2 April 2020.
