22,328
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
m
| align="center" | Judge Jeffrey Dana Gillen
EFFECTIVE JUNE 1, Effective 01 June 2015 JUDGE GILLEN WILL BE ROTATING TO CIRCUIT CIVIL DIVISION Judge Gillen has rotated to circuit civil division "AE".
add image description
|-
| align="right" | [[Image:Jeffrey_Gillen.jpg|175px]]
|-
| align="center" | Judge [[{{FULLPAGENAME}}]]
|-
|- style="background: #DCDCDC"
|}
During the original audience, Gillen ignored medical expert Charles Flack's argument that C.R.N.H. had no medical need for circumcision, that he wouldn't circumcise a son at that age, instead promoting dubious arguments of benefits, indicating in the ruling: '"that penile cancer occurs only in uncircumcised males and uncircumcised males have a higher risk of HIV infection than circumcised males. He further testified that the procedure last only 17 minutes and patients experience little post-operative discomfort and few recovery problems. Finally, he testified that performing the procedure on boys up to 10 years of age is medically acceptable, the concern being that with older boys who have reached puberty, an erection could cause tears in the sutures."'<ref>{{REFweb
| quote= | url=http://circwatch.org/dr-charles-e-flack-expert-in-the-case-of-chase/ | title=Dr. Charles E. Flack – the expert witness in the case of Chase | last= | first= | publisher= | website=CircWatch | date=2014-11-17 | accessdate=2015-05-28
}}</ref>
Gillen also dismissed [[Heather Hironimus]]' fear of the risk of death due to general anesthesia.
On 10 March 102015, while Hironimus was hiding at a domestic violence shelter, Gillen said he wanted to "reign in this case," and added that circumcision is "short, under local anesthesia, and, and the stage of the boy's life, is very, very safe."<ref>{{REFweb | quote= | url=http://www.browardpalmbeach.com/news/mother-of-boy-in-circumcision-case-has-vanished-with-child-judge-orders-her-to-return-6885606 | title=Mother of Boy in Circumcision Case Has Vanished With Child; Judge Orders Her to Return | last=Joseph | first=Chris | publisher= | website=Broward Palm Beach New Times | date=2015-03-06 | accessdate=2015-05-28
}}</ref> This statement is not true, circumcision after the age of 1 typically requires general anesthesia, and according to the CDC the risks after the age of 1 grow 20 times.<ref>{{REFweb
| quote= | url=http://www.techtimes.com/articles/6949/20140513/circumcision-risk-grows-20-fold-after-first-birthday-in-boys-warns-new-study.htm | title=Circumcision risk grows 20-fold after first birthday in boys, warns new study | last=McKalin | first=Vamien | publisher= | website=Tech Times | date=2014-05-13 | accessdate=2015-05-28
}}</ref>. This day, Judge Gillen signed a writ of bodily attachment, calling Hironimus' fears "irrelevant at this point".
Hironimus was arrested on 14 May 14th 2015 and appeared in Judge Gillen's court on 22 May 22nd2015. Judge Gillen demanded she sign the consent form for circumcision. Hironimus initially declined. Gillen informed her that she would be detained indefinitely until she signs the agreement. Hironimus then changed her mind, and signed the papers handcuffed and visibly altered.
{{LINKS}}