22,226
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
created
'''{{FULLPAGENAME}}''' is an anonymous Facebook page. Because it links to the interesting and informative website ''Judaism 101'' by a Tracey Rich<ref>{{REFweb
|url=https://www.jewfaq.org/about
|title=About Judaism 101
|accessdate=2022-12-15
}}</ref>, one could assume that the Facebook page is also from Tracey Rich.
== Claim ==
{{Citation
|Text=This page is devoted to exposing the [[anti-Semitic]] roots of [[intactivism]].
|Author={{FULLPAGENAME}}
}}
== IntactiWiki comment ==
The claim of this Facebook page implicates that [[intactivism]] must be [[anti-Semitic]] from its beginning - without giving any proof. Thus, one can assume that underlying the charge that [[intactivism]] is inherently [[anti-Semitic]] is the assumption that criticism of something Jews do to children is inherently [[anti-Semitic]] - which it is not.
The page has a few followers and low traffic. The tone of that page is very arrogant and overbearing. People who, like the late [[Rosemary Romberg]] (wife of a Jew and an [[intactivism]] pioneer), openly approached the site's creators and declared that [[intactivism]] is not rooted in [[anti-Semitism]] but in a desire to protect all children from violence, are ridiculed and lampooned.<ref>{{REFweb
|url=https://www.facebook.com/AntisemiticRootsofIntactivism/posts/pfbid02qBXvJ3nEzTkm26LvvzATpLzZPpcx1CiW7sx5qoMh8payCU8LAaReiShCbTAMSdB5l?comment_id=2289097324710370
|title=I don't really understand this site ...
|last=Romberg
|first=Rosemary
|init=R
|author-link=Rosemary Romberg
|publisher=Facebook
|date=2019
|accessdate=2022-12-15
}}</ref> Other comments of people on that Facebook page seem to have been removed so that only (rather rude) comments of the page owners are still visible.
On this basis, such a site can do little to protect children (or even protect Jews from [[anti-Semitism]], even if the notion of not mixing [[intactivism]] and [[anti-Semitism]] is important, of course. The impression remains that this site just wants to lash out instead of dealing with factual criticism of the bloody ritual of [[circumcision]] of boys.
{{SEEALSO}}
* [[Antisemitism in Intactivism]]
{{LINKS}}
* {{URL-FBpage|AntisemiticRootsofIntactivism|2022-12-15}}
{{REF}}
[[Category:Jewish]]
[[Category:Observation]]
|url=https://www.jewfaq.org/about
|title=About Judaism 101
|accessdate=2022-12-15
}}</ref>, one could assume that the Facebook page is also from Tracey Rich.
== Claim ==
{{Citation
|Text=This page is devoted to exposing the [[anti-Semitic]] roots of [[intactivism]].
|Author={{FULLPAGENAME}}
}}
== IntactiWiki comment ==
The claim of this Facebook page implicates that [[intactivism]] must be [[anti-Semitic]] from its beginning - without giving any proof. Thus, one can assume that underlying the charge that [[intactivism]] is inherently [[anti-Semitic]] is the assumption that criticism of something Jews do to children is inherently [[anti-Semitic]] - which it is not.
The page has a few followers and low traffic. The tone of that page is very arrogant and overbearing. People who, like the late [[Rosemary Romberg]] (wife of a Jew and an [[intactivism]] pioneer), openly approached the site's creators and declared that [[intactivism]] is not rooted in [[anti-Semitism]] but in a desire to protect all children from violence, are ridiculed and lampooned.<ref>{{REFweb
|url=https://www.facebook.com/AntisemiticRootsofIntactivism/posts/pfbid02qBXvJ3nEzTkm26LvvzATpLzZPpcx1CiW7sx5qoMh8payCU8LAaReiShCbTAMSdB5l?comment_id=2289097324710370
|title=I don't really understand this site ...
|last=Romberg
|first=Rosemary
|init=R
|author-link=Rosemary Romberg
|publisher=Facebook
|date=2019
|accessdate=2022-12-15
}}</ref> Other comments of people on that Facebook page seem to have been removed so that only (rather rude) comments of the page owners are still visible.
On this basis, such a site can do little to protect children (or even protect Jews from [[anti-Semitism]], even if the notion of not mixing [[intactivism]] and [[anti-Semitism]] is important, of course. The impression remains that this site just wants to lash out instead of dealing with factual criticism of the bloody ritual of [[circumcision]] of boys.
{{SEEALSO}}
* [[Antisemitism in Intactivism]]
{{LINKS}}
* {{URL-FBpage|AntisemiticRootsofIntactivism|2022-12-15}}
{{REF}}
[[Category:Jewish]]
[[Category:Observation]]