Circumcision methods: Difference between revisions

(6 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)

Line 2:

[[Circumcision]] is performed in many ways which vary by culture, the person performing it, and the age of the subject. It may be performed by a specialized ritual circumciser in a non-medical setting, or a medical practitioner at a hospital or clinic. In some cultures, only the protruding end of the [[foreskin]] is cut off, and in others, the entire foreskin which covers the [[glans]] is removed. Some circumcisers take more [[skin]] than others, resulting in a "loose" or "tight" circumcision.

Generally, the foreskin is pulled forward and enough of it is removed to permanently expose the glans of the penis. Sometimes a protective device is used to avoid hurting the glans, and sometimes the circumciser simply performs the procedure freehand. In adults, stitches are used to stop the [[bleeding]] and help close the wound. In infants, circumcisers often use a clamp that crushes the foreskin and seals the wound, eliminating the need for stitches.

Generally, the [[foreskin]] is pulled forward and enough of it is removed to permanently expose the [[glans]] of the [[penis]]. Sometimes a protective device is used to avoid hurting the glans, and sometimes the circumciser simply performs the procedure freehand. In adults, stitches are used to stop the [[bleeding]] and help close the wound. In infants, circumcisers often use a clamp that crushes the foreskin and seals the wound, eliminating the need for stitches.

== Circumcision in detail: ~~Styles,~~ techniques and instruments ==

== Circumcision in detail: techniques and instruments ==

During circumcision, the [[foreskin]] of the [[penis]] is partly or completely removed. The exact amount and type of [[skin]] removed depends on the style and technique used, and therefore also on the tools being used.

~~=== Common styles ===~~

~~==== High & Tight ====~~

~~[[Image:Penis_unlabeled.jpg|200px|center]]~~

~~This style is the most common in the USA. In this style, the outer [[foreskin]], parts of the inner [[foreskin]] and parts of the [[shaft skin]] are removed.~~

~~The remaining part of the inner [[foreskin]] is folded back and sewed to the [[shaft skin]]. The scar is located closer to the body, hence the term "high".~~

The inner [[foreskin]], which originally faced inwards lying on the [[Glans penis|glans]], now faces outward; this causes the differently coloured section between [[Glans penis|glans]] and [[shaft skin]] which is characteristic for this style.

Of all styles, the tight ones remove the most [[skin]]. They already limit the mobility of the [[penile skin]] to a great extent when the [[penis]] is flaccid, and during an [[erection]] the [[skin]] is fully stretched and immobile. An insufficient amount of reserve [[skin]] can hamper a complete [[erection]] and lead to painful tension. Also, a skewed [[penis]] can occur due to an uneven distribution of the remaining [[skin]], often caused by an inaccurately placed cut or a uneven growth during wound healing. Due to the extensive shortening of the inner [[foreskin]], this style also means the loss of large amounts of sensitive tissue.

~~==== Low & Tight ====~~

~~[[Image:Low_and_tight.jpg|200px|center]]~~

In this style, both the inner and outer [[foreskin]] are completely removed. The [[shaft skin]] is sewed just below the rim of the [[Glans penis|glans]]. The scar is located close the [[Glans penis|glans]], hence the term "low".

This style is the most radical, as it removes the entire sensitive tissue of the [[foreskin]]. As in the high & tight style, large amounts of [[skin]] are removed. In a flaccid state, the [[skin]] is barely movable, and in an erect state it is totally immobile.

~~An insufficient amount of reserve [[skin]] can hamper an [[erection]] and lead to painful tension and a skewed [[penis]] in this style as well.~~

~~==== High & Loose ====~~

~~[[image:High_and_loose.jpg|200px|center]]~~

The outer foreskin is completely removed, as well as parts of the [[shaft skin]]. The inner foreskin is folded back and sewed to the [[shaft skin]]. The scar is located towards the body, hence the term "high". Unlike the high & tight style, the inner [[foreskin]] is less reduced, and lies in folds behind the [[Glans penis|glans]].

~~There is enough remaining reserve [[skin]] to ensure a complete and unhindered [[erection]]. Of all variants, this one removes the smallest amount of sensitive tissue.~~

~~==== Low & Loose ====~~

~~[[image:Low_and_loose.jpg|200px|center]]~~

The inner [[foreskin]] is removed, the outer [[foreskin]] is sewed on below the [[Glans penis|glans]]. The scar is therefore located close to the [[Glans penis|glans]], hence the term "low". The outer [[foreskin]] lies in folds behind the [[Glans penis|glans]]. Enough [[skin]] is left in place to ensure a complete and unhindered [[erection]].

~~Since, in contrast to the high & loose style, the inner instead of the outer [[foreskin]] is removed, this style results in the loss of almost all of the sensitive tissue.~~

=== Techniques and instruments ===

Over time, a vast variety of methods has been developed to remove the [[foreskin]]. A multitude of clamps and tools is available to ease the work of the circumciser, to improve the chance for visually symmetrical results and to prevent injuries to the [[Glans penis|glans]] from inexpert cuts. I will introduce some of the most widely spread variants.

====Restraint====

When an infant boy is to be [[circumcised]], it is the usual practice to immobilize the infant for the [[Pain| painful]] surgery by securely tying his limbs to a molded plastic board specially made for that purpose. The infant thus is preventing from fighting or fleeing, which is the [[trauma]]-producing situation of ''inescapable [[shock]]'', described as a "physical condition in which the organism cannot do anything to affect the inevitable."<ref name="vanderkolk2014">{{REFbook

When an infant boy is to be [[circumcised]], it is the usual practice to immobilize the infant for the [[Pain| painful]] surgery by securely tying his limbs to a molded plastic board, called a [[Circumstraint]], specially made for that purpose. The infant thus is preventing from fighting or fleeing, which is the [[trauma]]-producing situation of ''inescapable [[shock]]'', described as a "physical condition in which the organism cannot do anything to affect the inevitable."<ref name="vanderkolk2014">{{REFbook

|last=van der Kolk

|first=Bessel A.

Line 72:

Line 40:

[[File:Circumpendium-6-2-1-Mogen-clamp.jpg||center|thumb|Mogen-clamp]]

The Mogen-Clamp works in a similar way (middle), with the difference that it is locked shut after the [[foreskin]] is inserted, thus clamping it. After a few minutes the [[foreskin]] is cut in the same fashion as with the simple shield. The clamping is meant to reduce or prevent [[bleeding]] from the wound.

The [[Mogen]]-Clamp works in a similar way (middle), with the difference that it is locked shut after the [[foreskin]] is inserted, thus clamping it. After a few minutes the [[foreskin]] is cut in the same fashion as with the simple shield. The clamping is meant to reduce or prevent [[bleeding]] from the wound.

[[File:Circumpendium-6-2-1-Sheldon-clamp.jpg||center|thumb|Sheldon-Clamp]]

The Sheldon-Clamp (right) works in a similar way. The inner clamp grasps the tip of the [[foreskin]], pulling it into the outer clamp which is closed. The outer clamp then grips the [[skin]]. After a few minutes of pressure, the [[foreskin]] is cut between the two clamps.

The use of a shield, rather than forceps, is meant to provide a better protection of the [[Glans penis|glans]] from cutting injuries. However, if used improperly both the Mogen and the Sheldon clamp are subject to the risk of the tip of the [[Glans penis|glans]] being accidentally clamped and being cut into or severed.

The use of a shield, rather than forceps, is meant to provide a better protection of the [[Glans penis|glans]] from cutting injuries. However, if used improperly both the [[Mogen]] and the Sheldon clamp are subject to the risk of the tip of the [[Glans penis|glans]] being accidentally clamped and being cut into or severed.

==== Complex clamps ====

[[File:Circumpendium-6-2-2-Gomco-clamp.jpg|center|thumb|Gomco clamp]]

One of the most widely used clamps in the USA is the Gomco clamp. First, a cut is placed into the [[foreskin]], then the metal bell is placed over the [[Glans penis|glans]]. After that, the bell, together with the [[foreskin]], is pulled through the opening in the base plate and hung into the lever. By fastening the screw the lever pulls the bell upwards, jamming the [[foreskin]] between bell and base plate. After several minutes of clamping, the [[skin]] is cut off with a scalpel along the upper side of the base plate and the clamp removed.

One of the most widely used clamps in the USA is the [[Gomco]] clamp. First, a cut is placed into the [[foreskin]], then the metal bell is placed over the [[Glans penis|glans]]. After that, the bell, together with the [[foreskin]], is pulled through the opening in the base plate and hung into the lever. By fastening the screw the lever pulls the bell upwards, jamming the [[foreskin]] between bell and base plate. After several minutes of clamping, the [[skin]] is cut off with a scalpel along the upper side of the base plate and the clamp removed.

[[File:Circumpendium-6-2-2-plastibell.jpg|center|thumb|Plastibell method]]

Line 89:

Line 57:

[[File:Circumpendium-6-2-2-Smartclamp.jpg|center|thumb|Smartclamp]]

The Smartclamp and a couple of similar designs are one way clamps, representing a mixture of the [[Gomco]] and [[Plastibell]] methods. The [[Glans penis|glans]] is inserted into the plastic tube, the [[foreskin]] pulled over it. The base plate of the outer clamping mechanism is pushed over the [[foreskin]] and cocked shut, jamming the [[foreskin]] between the bulging lower rim of the tube and the lower base plate. The [[foreskin]] is now cut off along the upper side of the base plate. The entire clamping mechanism remains on the [[penis]], until it - like the [[Plastibell]] - falls off by itself after the clamped [[skin]] dies off in the following days.

The Smartclamp and a couple of similar designs are one way clamps, representing a mixture of the [[Gomco]] and [[Plastibell]] methods. The [[Glans penis|glans]] is inserted into the plastic tube, the [[foreskin]] pulled over it. The base plate of the outer clamping mechanism is pushed over the [[foreskin]] and cocked shut, jamming the [[foreskin]] between the bulging lower rim of the tube and the lower base plate. The [[foreskin]] is now cut off along the upper side of the base plate. The entire clamping mechanism remains on the [[penis]], until it — like the [[Plastibell]] — falls off by itself after the clamped [[skin]] dies off in the following days.

All of these methods have in common that the [[foreskin]] has to be separated from the [[Glans penis|glans]] first. In case of the circumcision of a child, it is in most cases (see chart above) necessary to forcibly tear apart the [[synechia| balanopreputial membrane]], which fuses the [[foreskin]] to the [[Glans penis|glans]], either by violently retracting the [[foreskin]] or separating it by pushing a blunt instrument underneath the [[foreskin]], both of which can result in injuries and inflammations of the [[Glans penis|glans]].

* [[Circumcision instruments]]

* [[Pain]]

* [[Trauma]]

~~{{REF}}~~

[[Category:Body modification]]

[[Category:Circumcision]]

[[Category:Education]]

[[Category:Genital cutting]]

[[Category:Genital surgery]]

[[Category:Male genital mutilation]]

[[Category:Penis]]

[[Category:Trauma]]

[[de:Beschneidungsmethoden]]

@@ Line 2: / Line 2: @@
 [[Circumcision]] is performed in many ways which vary by culture, the person performing it, and the age of the subject. It may be performed by a specialized ritual circumciser in a non-medical setting, or a medical practitioner at a hospital or clinic. In some cultures, only the protruding end of the [[foreskin]] is cut off, and in others, the entire foreskin which covers the [[glans]] is removed. Some circumcisers take more [[skin]] than others, resulting in a "loose" or "tight" circumcision.
-Generally, the foreskin is pulled forward and enough of it is removed to permanently expose the glans of the penis. Sometimes a protective device is used to avoid hurting the glans, and sometimes the circumciser simply performs the procedure freehand. In adults, stitches are used to stop the [[bleeding]] and help close the wound. In infants, circumcisers often use a clamp that crushes the foreskin and seals the wound, eliminating the need for stitches.
+Generally, the [[foreskin]] is pulled forward and enough of it is removed to permanently expose the [[glans]] of the [[penis]]. Sometimes a protective device is used to avoid hurting the glans, and sometimes the circumciser simply performs the procedure freehand. In adults, stitches are used to stop the [[bleeding]] and help close the wound. In infants, circumcisers often use a clamp that crushes the foreskin and seals the wound, eliminating the need for stitches.
-== Circumcision in detail: Styles, techniques and instruments ==
+== Circumcision in detail: techniques and instruments ==
 During circumcision, the [[foreskin]] of the [[penis]] is partly or completely removed. The exact amount and type of [[skin]] removed depends on the style and technique used, and therefore also on the tools being used.
-=== Common styles ===
-==== High & Tight ====
-[[Image:Penis_unlabeled.jpg|200px|center]]
-This style is the most common in the USA. In this style, the outer [[foreskin]], parts of the inner [[foreskin]] and parts of the [[shaft skin]] are removed.
-The remaining part of the inner [[foreskin]] is folded back and sewed to the [[shaft skin]]. The scar is located closer to the body, hence the term "high".
-The inner [[foreskin]], which originally faced inwards lying on the [[Glans penis|glans]], now faces outward; this causes the differently coloured section between [[Glans penis|glans]] and [[shaft skin]] which is characteristic for this style.
-Of all styles, the tight ones remove the most [[skin]]. They already limit the mobility of the [[penile skin]] to a great extent when the [[penis]] is flaccid, and during an [[erection]] the [[skin]] is fully stretched and immobile. An insufficient amount of reserve [[skin]] can hamper a complete [[erection]] and lead to painful tension. Also, a skewed [[penis]] can occur due to an uneven distribution of the remaining [[skin]], often caused by an inaccurately placed cut or a uneven growth during wound healing. Due to the extensive shortening of the inner [[foreskin]], this style also means the loss of large amounts of sensitive tissue.
-==== Low & Tight ====
-[[Image:Low_and_tight.jpg|200px|center]]
-In this style, both the inner and outer [[foreskin]] are completely removed. The [[shaft skin]] is sewed just below the rim of the [[Glans penis|glans]]. The scar is located close the [[Glans penis|glans]], hence the term "low".
-This style is the most radical, as it removes the entire sensitive tissue of the [[foreskin]]. As in the high & tight style, large amounts of [[skin]] are removed. In a flaccid state, the [[skin]] is barely movable, and in an erect state it is totally immobile.
-An insufficient amount of reserve [[skin]] can hamper an [[erection]] and lead to painful tension and a skewed [[penis]] in this style as well.
-==== High & Loose ====
-[[image:High_and_loose.jpg|200px|center]]
-The outer foreskin is completely removed, as well as parts of the [[shaft skin]]. The inner foreskin is folded back and sewed to the [[shaft skin]]. The scar is located towards the body, hence the term "high". Unlike the high & tight style, the inner [[foreskin]] is less reduced, and lies in folds behind the [[Glans penis|glans]].
-There is enough remaining reserve [[skin]] to ensure a complete and unhindered [[erection]]. Of all variants, this one removes the smallest amount of sensitive tissue.
-==== Low & Loose ====
-[[image:Low_and_loose.jpg|200px|center]]
-The inner [[foreskin]] is removed, the outer [[foreskin]] is sewed on below the [[Glans penis|glans]]. The scar is therefore located close to the [[Glans penis|glans]], hence the term "low". The outer [[foreskin]] lies in folds behind the [[Glans penis|glans]]. Enough [[skin]] is left in place to ensure a complete and unhindered [[erection]].
-Since, in contrast to the high & loose style, the inner instead of the outer [[foreskin]] is removed, this style results in the loss of almost all of the sensitive tissue.
 === Techniques and instruments ===
 Over time, a vast variety of methods has been developed to remove the [[foreskin]]. A multitude of clamps and tools is available to ease the work of the circumciser, to improve the chance for visually symmetrical results and to prevent injuries to the [[Glans penis|glans]] from inexpert cuts. I will introduce some of the most widely spread variants.
 ====Restraint====
-When an infant boy is to be [[circumcised]], it is the usual practice to immobilize the infant for the [[Pain| painful]] surgery by securely tying his limbs to a molded plastic board specially made for that purpose. The infant thus is preventing from fighting or fleeing, which is the [[trauma]]-producing situation of ''inescapable [[shock]]'', described as a "physical condition in which the organism cannot do anything to affect the inevitable."<ref name="vanderkolk2014">{{REFbook
+When an infant boy is to be [[circumcised]], it is the usual practice to immobilize the infant for the [[Pain| painful]] surgery by securely tying his limbs to a molded plastic board, called a [[Circumstraint]], specially made for that purpose. The infant thus is preventing from fighting or fleeing, which is the [[trauma]]-producing situation of ''inescapable [[shock]]'', described as a "physical condition in which the organism cannot do anything to affect the inevitable."<ref name="vanderkolk2014">{{REFbook
   |last=van der Kolk
   |first=Bessel A.
@@ Line 72: / Line 40: @@
 [[File:Circumpendium-6-2-1-Mogen-clamp.jpg||center|thumb|Mogen-clamp]]
-The Mogen-Clamp works in a similar way (middle), with the difference that it is locked shut after the [[foreskin]] is inserted, thus clamping it. After a few minutes the [[foreskin]] is cut in the same fashion as with the simple shield. The clamping is meant to reduce or prevent [[bleeding]] from the wound.
+The [[Mogen]]-Clamp works in a similar way (middle), with the difference that it is locked shut after the [[foreskin]] is inserted, thus clamping it. After a few minutes the [[foreskin]] is cut in the same fashion as with the simple shield. The clamping is meant to reduce or prevent [[bleeding]] from the wound.
 [[File:Circumpendium-6-2-1-Sheldon-clamp.jpg||center|thumb|Sheldon-Clamp]]
 The Sheldon-Clamp (right) works in a similar way. The inner clamp grasps the tip of the [[foreskin]], pulling it into the outer clamp which is closed. The outer clamp then grips the [[skin]]. After a few minutes of pressure, the [[foreskin]] is cut between the two clamps.
-The use of a shield, rather than forceps, is meant to provide a better protection of the [[Glans penis|glans]] from cutting injuries. However, if used improperly both the Mogen and the Sheldon clamp are subject to the risk of the tip of the [[Glans penis|glans]] being accidentally clamped and being cut into or severed.
+The use of a shield, rather than forceps, is meant to provide a better protection of the [[Glans penis|glans]] from cutting injuries. However, if used improperly both the [[Mogen]] and the Sheldon clamp are subject to the risk of the tip of the [[Glans penis|glans]] being accidentally clamped and being cut into or severed.
 ==== Complex clamps ====
 [[File:Circumpendium-6-2-2-Gomco-clamp.jpg|center|thumb|Gomco clamp]]
-One of the most widely used clamps in the USA is the Gomco clamp. First, a cut is placed into the [[foreskin]], then the metal bell is placed over the [[Glans penis|glans]]. After that, the bell, together with the [[foreskin]], is pulled through the opening in the base plate and hung into the lever. By fastening the screw the lever pulls the bell upwards, jamming the [[foreskin]] between bell and base plate. After several minutes of clamping, the [[skin]] is cut off with a scalpel along the upper side of the base plate and the clamp removed.
+One of the most widely used clamps in the USA is the [[Gomco]] clamp. First, a cut is placed into the [[foreskin]], then the metal bell is placed over the [[Glans penis|glans]]. After that, the bell, together with the [[foreskin]], is pulled through the opening in the base plate and hung into the lever. By fastening the screw the lever pulls the bell upwards, jamming the [[foreskin]] between bell and base plate. After several minutes of clamping, the [[skin]] is cut off with a scalpel along the upper side of the base plate and the clamp removed.
 [[File:Circumpendium-6-2-2-plastibell.jpg|center|thumb|Plastibell method]]
@@ Line 89: / Line 57: @@
 [[File:Circumpendium-6-2-2-Smartclamp.jpg|center|thumb|Smartclamp]]
-The Smartclamp and a couple of similar designs are one way clamps, representing a mixture of the [[Gomco]] and [[Plastibell]] methods. The [[Glans penis|glans]] is inserted into the plastic tube, the [[foreskin]] pulled over it. The base plate of the outer clamping mechanism is pushed over the [[foreskin]] and cocked shut, jamming the [[foreskin]] between the bulging lower rim of the tube and the lower base plate. The [[foreskin]] is now cut off along the upper side of the base plate. The entire clamping mechanism remains on the [[penis]], until it - like the [[Plastibell]] - falls off by itself after the clamped [[skin]] dies off in the following days.
+The Smartclamp and a couple of similar designs are one way clamps, representing a mixture of the [[Gomco]] and [[Plastibell]] methods. The [[Glans penis|glans]] is inserted into the plastic tube, the [[foreskin]] pulled over it. The base plate of the outer clamping mechanism is pushed over the [[foreskin]] and cocked shut, jamming the [[foreskin]] between the bulging lower rim of the tube and the lower base plate. The [[foreskin]] is now cut off along the upper side of the base plate. The entire clamping mechanism remains on the [[penis]], until it — like the [[Plastibell]] — falls off by itself after the clamped [[skin]] dies off in the following days.
 All of these methods have in common that the [[foreskin]] has to be separated from the [[Glans penis|glans]] first. In case of the circumcision of a child, it is in most cases (see chart above) necessary to forcibly tear apart the [[synechia| balanopreputial membrane]], which fuses the [[foreskin]] to the [[Glans penis|glans]], either by violently retracting the [[foreskin]] or separating it by pushing a blunt instrument underneath the [[foreskin]], both of which can result in injuries and inflammations of the [[Glans penis|glans]].
+{{SEEALSO}}
+* [[Circumcision instruments]]
+* [[Pain]]
+* [[Trauma]]
+{{REF}}
-{{REF}}
+[[Category:Body modification]]
+[[Category:Circumcision]]
+[[Category:Education]]
+[[Category:Genital cutting]]
 [[Category:Genital surgery]]
+[[Category:Male genital mutilation]]
+[[Category:Penis]]
+[[Category:Trauma]]
 [[de:Beschneidungsmethoden]]